From 2c7938418a149d56964ef8ea4457bd2e8277e5c6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: afanfakh <afanfakh@fanfakh.afanfakh> Date: Wed, 26 Mar 2014 10:55:46 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] updates --- fig/compare_class_A.pdf | Bin 27371 -> 27360 bytes fig/compare_class_B.pdf | Bin 27591 -> 27590 bytes fig/compare_class_C.pdf | Bin 27244 -> 27237 bytes paper.tex | 10 +++++----- 4 files changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/fig/compare_class_A.pdf b/fig/compare_class_A.pdf index 5b3c8041d884ea17d087bfcaa296c20acb07c554..33172d06c43f7d8287bd85f095054f6971469b5f 100644 GIT binary patch delta 2337 zcmah_c{r47A8v#+j#5n`Vfu#BSmu3a=6z?z+L$pyUv|ct!H9^gS#l<tl!){yD%I!^ zSyCpX(jt^jS(;;4$(ksMu~hhUzVEuumHzmC|2)6vzV7E<p3zoRZ!7AwCC@T=3+1;5 zO{H03E3BB+Qj)R*gA!GFP&1?1^`dmVyP#@dJTsRpj5*j&64$T^{=Bd1Hdi!XTI&Fd z*$bC8E-04zs`P*FFCCe2nlzqjm%^wUA6}e|jhO+iD-G#CN)&7|bS=-Cd*>e$x0WOj zi%%tpp3JD8)k{$Y8~aNYcwAP-IOzC@uMw$9xtgHD`ebHrztTzGy5b2FwINgWEX%&k zQcWx8AtnUn`d9ZlsprOO)+-c!HES_gZNqMT)HROcL%_1x8_3;rN`*Y(am2Yj-be<! z%5v=ndl_BboTG6V&o^rVZ4W-VW5^%mdrDWtq7)+3+^pBXm<hy=@yvGt#RXW`T|sP{ zt@m9<IHt!w?>{@ucRH%v!T-G9-nDe?n(?Q{M<%DDha`{d*WKZ7ZU+U`*Jy!9jI&;0 z)w2Z`u55drm?rcR(33CZHR5W!`a%}qxHxFXmJeU&#G4umjVC5ok36(G?dLD2(<AbU zmu5`&zo-~GW)?K6e2?c@Sf3`U9HC@qxR^9Fe4J?pCyz!3R0=lKe+b!jW-&QMVG{wD zJQu2-C*dwAirWw<xbJwg?t#>~Tz_<Ad2m8qE#eq>D>xpy50ZY|P0uT+yAtXgUMc4| zRc1{nuJEpy=MIF7nN{7q+8nbLzh2PW@c^|xqhE9I^sO*uUSQG!$+?%>cAhJHI5Oy{ zTux2mL9JrPBYIjLV?EMEugkcdOJ{)HG43$THc0=T$Q{n>h!|hJ^R8d1n!&kK=<MT$ z<LH&?R_mI+d5OzDIQoo&q4-tdPl~Hw6TzXT-omilD93#SoGSsx^)0DL#|m>~+v>Bc zneB-QMIU(yXV~T?v$MVDG5>O(?|l3Xr616p5>WjcW|eGxAf4%9xv8rpWLo~Q2dm=E zSwP((FZ6J@fe7D)<K!G}5Y$&GtQ-ZSQYD8ZQeUL|b+{;lf)GW!JMS-N80QvS7#3)M zH>%XW{HLAHv$lZkZ-91}8gbf#3l0;-2g2K;+OxEHI$KHjF9zZ<|1Iu4;cYSPS;>j^ zdt^`B-Wr*Xe&7^tQPlMeyfMfxZge=5)aTs0PQho?UAeUIwv_ejxU&4m2iN$PI7H^( zNF)W|%^sQc4Cpqcd@SeSD#Mab+2j|z=;0x6@W)zOSq=tumRtAElgh+hY`3vIM`gVF zrAb^TFZ`Q9(M|E)XKtTzY*k+C|GWHJrzk7prE~hJ%0sIAS~+TXhf&x2H;t4drW>9A za$!nE@6`#J_&m*R)H_gJEiA||Z^GYwKG7+1oM>^f?~aO%y*@QZK4#Bd9HVwH-Ofh{ zF2{BbQ%m~bgt>Q3b7I44`<ka?gsF2)u`#ua{k(T}zxVu}ir4tyc9pojXk@-A2(On; z9}3+bmV*D1v%_W%5ltC!D4FodH8M$Bmv^>YygBa{MY15acZ*cA7&-aKXpQ>YiASls z&+rR(OoGUDNluh~z38NBe^|I2W=?yu>geJ48ylTwQ&XB++Uk<$rD|}D<T;&{)xjkN z&v`{9D>1MfCdgQ-ZZq5CH9z%f;&t1Mq*P|&iQ8?4Eg=w?E-q@0EqvmQ-k<wrzToTA zBfHY#r|x*pp>RQ}?&1zvd~8dq2MgBzQl5v+_Nb{+o38kM_P}&~PjpHkJJL;p*i}<y zCOf<kSogLgrL*hYA0MO3?LzD2r<_L(ukaMr_8e+!{^o7LnVC|?EUxaA9Fco3y3}^t zYVDZyCwXs<M~8-Ls;33Zpv&;Bl<t<w?5`7&k5tpLL(xqd_dd;jx$#|AZj)JZ|L&dP z3h&idd{6f7_6$zf(-_9-_eSp-x9YM1cIUoqT$JJ0XdXm%K4xF66<tb`dby&tPtaw~ z8@x1cnS2JoDDfpu*u~-%f{J6!x#q(B%Y!283IvS=y|=;d{t$18-<=wPxlX1jaC2V` zumxu=5PwZ0bE%z!$93!aa#hjZULnLaj19?1%!y)l_Lj^MlaMk(_Vc<1&NZ)S+qHJ` ze<J>D>stmR(iO6U4Jxg^G7Ke!+)!Oo{*20CgL|DhR2<LFzRjT4_6<<2Zc%CHT9<T{ zI&%BeQ|=Y&?patRGx|~uiIP^4ppcPFX#?SBCR=4Aj0Ld4Ui;A$GKGrf2KoHh(a2t} zJBXYTPH5nL0EM`2CLo<Ye<0(VorEIk@O6j|eYGT+Oo9+SIuYS3CL!~54I!YUg+huL z0CI9O7s+J02+fp-HBc}@pl@7~(?kO4XAnhi4I$1X3568;5Rh(0H4?`qVQ5PUYzZtP z_J0cr3zCJkT#m#l7zD@=Kt;6uXc8b1+2^;72a~bDkHH3E(SI*Qm<U13FaU(9zhE>X znYx@uBf?9jKj{H9G6nbrqe7&=G2TDMAOO%P%ZMNu2A7*GVdUk4Ael;9`uLxWK?sDF zmjfXZ>8F6ar6)uPpe=7lgg|h47$QU>g3C;Z5QX&LCjS&6!T|7#9t=Rg=)ojt<MM<= zm<)l4+I~YG2$@h|7DT6+&;XDMz$SDiNCZqxiDa576Qn{$XoLSt!MdXf%wTVZAJ;n| zEaCu`K!R8%03D{lOcs?v1|b@a37eWQ$R>0OacNA^Mn>qca877=lzb@H7fpnhsAvrh IQ!5twKM?cNqyPW_ delta 2343 zcmaiydo)z*8^<G)43)|_h>T+760`T7*)!V=7RCrMLLoWsa=%kT6G@8Fu}>GJOhn@{ zPE3d*5z&q0GL#Cr=lnutYE);=Ie(m${`kHByzly~=leXL^{n?zuf$BR#2H(*UG_^@ zu0iA?RP`bhG-9My`qd6d))jehj&o|^HK_xVPqf%~HMJ5oGx@&zvs#~K-0oy;_{exz zVAL%16-GD<eebBmWsNT0J#P9c>wC9nHV6OtPm##9rDcJ`R9bgrU8>3Sv(iH4e9!b+ z7E!XM@s3mEp>H*eA`Ej;X=09DXqmft?7WhmS2JMXP+^66aq8tFmupmk=e(2Lh}lUu z*i~YsmALPV&7`5_z9z+wjaDi1wQATELvomW$+Xd&S+gTSlWm5NH^lx=uEfcgW=F>o zXB0V}QfH2iZXj^w_tDca?~blmsPRSfHhr1Z(ASoFUTG|IgM0odM(f@ZJ7-Orv5ZVT z4(BJ^5vQkn%SCU9$9?lFuUlm?I8yD>n_o`_yH6h-5)CH^Nl7Y5)37~YaJ4N?PH?4J z)#Qk&Qa4^RkE7zb>SX%FE}+XRbF-~%ru_4b6LT}~$DVLbUrp=yB&zj9n!h!@&KC66 zO5~VjhaC5CQ=!&8^$o9F!M?F>CMrWV^Ws9`#PG~}ntg?Tz=kfYsVAWYe2^>%jH)Jt z0-u_?zfqurRq^K1*g&Y>Rm9;NXn*jVO>1jM4JLhNkHWWTLs?hKFL#x9D|?hDcb%oX zI3y18)&dLPnm?`GVf&&1U)Qj514}*1JUUU@&qir0Hs=KmuRZaay;|W#<>Y3_cR(P$ zDHJCV2&6BKA1fLkqVk?t>WX2=)Dq||z8@h$&F7@z)IU`%NNv*!SNlCvID50@m(@Fa znV56RH&o>qYx~YTkEyJhCisN_(e2jmBmD<U`TVT7$lV1x=Vb1zl&z`;=gEh8<G_}? zDZ18*WvVc?id`K(Z-Gy8e&?9+A*X586?MUdFAs0^J#6Z4Kb3nt^Ie~h;DXLc9P<0l z_P%<u@Y?wLEe)m2%rKs6t#Xgj#%Uv<c#Y{``>r00RE&roop>nE?9?uY$Flcle0qdD z0<b650+@E*9#Cn+)ot%9{i^Y-f7*h_@NDhz$<6a7__N_YyDv6LJ0jx9Uqgdd^Yv%q zM<Y+v2igtjTV$oyC68xN{|GK?pU&;)>h)?=$Mj+qWoxfBY^$mcN5%?_G^M#)cGQp# z4_g1WTU2c88f*_$UU%^f&$kL^u_%Y`(1E-DN|}bkJEre_Za)v|RLSd2J=3w?ZR=L< ze4;9xlE|J2maY~$=#^mip1A2vjS6rM;mvY#)YSs)#xg>K!VnrR2;Q@4Z$*6cdiD6L zj@7qX=XDI@_TKD&a#e9_=>t))e<p5=^pVt1-q{!~!#cve-X>w7o6wsYR(|%fb3u}_ zc`0ZKhh8}AP7W~~syB~S4aL2d_)2a}E-2GYN??EAdEoe~=dJhhJJlC#m$vKD8}{Zt z%*!iwFY0ynS}4kG8ngGRiHaImtfOb^l}~i1^Y7lru{e{dVa6`EMtF<Yj}E*&XyfY= zAZ#ie1T9)Wr&knabT~&7>AIsq#<g>9jTls@zfgB7DaAhfkN089`7Ic`q}SW$!j#<* zNeY`WRuQ@~WsKIC-psqsDbuN+l6y22dLXM~pwy-L6M0k?+K1e}HfW$-Tvg%8{u)z= zjg9nh_&mmaOUc-A{q$0!S;V%en#s2h_Bafjtf>X7yc5QH9K8-=WzIhpT%^T(E~@M@ z)Mvu_dZ$(7Y9gn)nu}=e&nRJSk2}vP9B^lgQtb5`WxcYs%cjnWyw-TIoJffUEQclS zBO9+B;IO25L7m|O-b;=8=9dFn0oFt<YWVDx>@=78KU3yaCnN<qvkDE;PMY3>(Z77p zZ3|IYLz0+#7P+#s<+A=6!8-YbjdOV&D>}a?(1WaA5r2y}`My;iI~3VohjA;m8ku^- z_BDg>HB>IVyF})t`-ilO3=IX>yuD8Aqmn)BbQ3R<KZ5jXgGZ^3!_VW4ZH}>qqO6Z~ zHrj7JYa%MhcK-5Cw#jh{ifi3o(!@>bFLGV#@ffz#Kin1`=riYZ;0i7?|10RBbJ#$Z zA3evvRO0%rXGr1x{QhZ0XMJ`(x%H3{qEOBam?-Oyw=0T<A1va=I(N6SdU+|XOE)jm z?vLy@WmO6X&d;`vT%QtL8`1u7yVT(Dw{`s6!wfWRm6{}#jApH(^NY1(*Q0pN)lwu9 zL`L;B0n`mSfzE1f<x3msNubFDL)3@nkFvB~_;~uHmK=a5;v;;5u?P$!s5SzkOrIQd z6w%}_`J9wMA(|mt?bm>|)7<zSt6bD10C8^|s^+7EdT5?O`+W%f^;)44=rKPcT23fL zqx?w<BymSaLnep^kbhqg9^u#ddrL}_KnSFQWK<&%kpv-hUm$@^A>)aEAAC3-`_BV} zK^R`fhyaZI#9$Cuo+ZK{^m82vA};R-Q%ID582i7$L>K|Z!av9WFic%O1b`{Tf5ZP} z#eRTzkw0cB5D5Lm$jA@<*y0FC2H@p}Vnzj*g+Vg(lMG0vz{{mUSiG<0S(pe@e_{}f z`@!aK8JGlvs6wzYn?xi6WSB@q7!VU6flLO>AX*@nOe({i1W^&H36}nUOYk08Lq>$J zMWDZLNK9N9-q6wvU_urUg~Bw05Td!cIfX(2iDnj%nHVzxGS<Wd8x!jt9eYqd+CKm* P{t8qIR!hs0#l-#vWWmud diff --git a/fig/compare_class_B.pdf b/fig/compare_class_B.pdf index a879c0b54ce96d01bcc8c47306e1db198da20911..cdcd6659e2118d6930e2b055a32699d5e8276f38 100644 GIT binary patch delta 2175 zcmaixdpy(oAIDROnJ%NNWDT8Sw0*aIH)0rDZODB{<T8`C=F;Svxp$E+KT)BhTx;&y za%)j;(W)aQhr`Hi9i<D3DIJ~PALl&udpv%hzdn!G<N1EQ-mlN6{gqtXE4hm_p1bXZ zesG;=(p7q>N$-?I9x9j3aDvweRA%gFdWy)E9`L%+_u<U_)B*zQ@tLa1D}H9g(3GH* zg3_Iv8&wZel6h?<4(){4Z_#t#ia(mkxGNPp!oN2zV(vw5HP2rE2cx~Xu`O59ti+6w z&9uA6KkpRFO5d`dbw2rp9TmHlHxoF@%o}fxA+>1Co;VRO%OMUgXwOzncjUZ`wx84F zeRy;dBFVMWN@*`19{CXR6?i^JDC;7m8fZ2PjN+Ugn&lv^Ochc@Q0r3xQ?x~*-vqX> z==yq(#))CcaJOCJ>!<UxlY6$+1kK6fnq#)3fOL(thg<GJ>Dnqax%)W0$s5IDyO=VU z;0<zVUo`4(71<*si|-XD&`l{FdlC~@#qhSD8DFUC8ewl_gHs6#TukYZ?|_OX@->}% zcPgo8UC6sl+^VVM&ryJeu}3&bW9%1EUTWALY-$8KVDf;J_A6}8my~rHSpUi4YWJ~6 zD>h$982zkyaYbB5<EXX<@5_VCUeAu{{wiuvx&Mfv+p(E(4{$0`HEP;G!|d$9WrX>g zk+Ecti*mxA4eCGvAEvH9I=_j*@*k~M#)<nDj=tdr_XhcRAx|j@Ak{)c6id_-%mD3O z+I$uG#z*`aEKlzg^LkzCimBfCe!)NrzZ_G<!B7|&j)BUfBRpH-w7UL>#jKF9h8sFP z@~p1tEslI3K~-;j6xqCW1h$)Qic#d#BVZp1t2iU>Ev|Qb?ETc8eG2@{W2-8`-8U<_ zrKitsKz{LJ^tio4;Kahq!SnfLOc$i&QK`@n?dnKkmhc(7=+4OR3G6ZzacWK{^XY0n z+n~L~Wpf#?mmgb!a;+vYi%Wh$kvZp<pyTC&<QBc2ZeMFwvvp>etHzZh?v5RmFYb}u zIyLJ=(BGt-$ts#{@hx%fcf0D6q?BsReZ-TE2J}PZ-h&O1jm9(sV|5x|{`9djm{vE2 zFFZk=lPP7)?LT{)HpC88t>dGsh391s)@ynD9Lf(AvRf;u0*=;9{ze_Xl2eHFZMH*N zUrXP?Q{U`o(ecj<X}j(UaM_%a&kkmKVfUdAoT-_rUkA$&oO4leELYb}fv;;7T4Eww zajs*ZjH7w<s0N0YNI}1x3cGU6KyvWHad&GW>2)aPYJV*(H$&I(*)*iRPEZ9n<?t-J zJQoR0N)_ZqAL6A{eA3_%W9nzd%>Er>yWF)0&a5#oMm|H^=qfZ%cm10AsW!D`B5?2e z`M2R89boY`QjRV*CQlGDfezVr-rdkWMETxrZd6IMRbkkl0}ZB*He*hWmj@72cJ-HP z=t1+yiu}U{eRjQ&dCD!d>&L?B6p)Af<WmMeG?<}s=keYt-$J(k`1RIDDPv7*u5{6Z zv=55X0`$$YPP8FUJ{}AXQ-*mO?vg)|D+vlHp5L8|n=!utX^)Ot-Kr%geglmn2HJKK z?@J@C0%F-Fr7~~YLy7U-Ld~I!lS$hd<DH6l^`PW0kJX0AYSQz}x+W2H(vnBdGATNm z8hW>N6xQo&VoG2+c$v?Ci`Xn)(`tw6cMp`ys2r@>)t#T$pO0FIc79tcuf84XaZU|& zd)nT6<;#X$Nh;10`RXolgVY_RH*QWlx>1LG!(Td}WK9>DTIW{FF&d;L_?6<{*X*>F zG{?#!uCDX;>DvoW-uNsf8Vux_CcgLGsk-&c4V`$>#6<oIYf)0cwZh+w;PS5e-N}|p z<wXdtfne*`*`}i+t*6_G+5#KO!nYTN2qyIXwpS)tx6onPOxn9KZK<Tzu+(w)<3^}w znSWb@sSPauW0haJ_k*{q5My;`_|wk5siI<1dA9t3-u_|Rn~BQ9LVh^U!p*6qzV$yQ zLht$yv_w*ko1@DeN|>S2nSeAigf(m7tGeT}KCYFhr%s!7^dr!4A$xRXrem$wD|Xz} zY4{7A#@F?;eZ4BwERVOzI?4FowTHuKn#vVUp5*$Q^%=!m56;a;gJ%!KDofigRm8;Y zds1^pVR6ScMC881Eo_}dy>XwO^Lc&<<*det_FMa~&OW<6rO?Tdgjlguv1Z}gA=%0A zBXed#uY{;{^cJ=B7)8iR(CE%-#Yo@PAR2`=LJ`uH0*&Q>bj!e<Je(06_2a-faLC^m z0K^h-%QO@kB%qdSI3w);&_MKZ4n*UA@&mCT{%?-=PcRAuvCBa;7C<i#S<*1TvJf;D zi}`t$fL>k>jay3j_bhLzGl0XOmm4l=KN$iz9A>#8fHV539RLD9&w>Eqzm5MX41hSo z2JFAL`LPTL642=jM~OU;WQ7ArmUw`S!l1AiJQj_z0<Z);-ikmWkS&Q26N~?cz&#;* ztb+V3kNEqsj)xtC@1Yn`Fci>|LPBAeyzxuFfU&Z$FtS7~Jr$lpwtx_ckmFpRP;Nx% TT7M=40F6)}L|2z=M}hnWz#Ei? delta 2176 zcmaivd03L^8phLHCfv&<bHf;y%=F^}K42ynKuB`j7<V*FLqh^juEmI7r*bq+(=;3F zG^t5wX6AysxmA|txTU6LyBevPM5blO({%orx%6DudH;Ie-*w;j^W1kv<T^*>GIzrP zu91%+&E{#}*M@t&|9EHM_uUO6kt2_-Ci9RDU!m^RbGBLfY@}YIvn>O~Z3aT#mt8U@ zc66F<+vN%*n%vAty;=P;>Q^A~GiPyjd@=G<jJ#rhtV7EeyT=Y{NBIgr=FLlb=S3R8 zG2=`2D~Ue&9uocDuKN}OpE!HZM?DMhwdI7uIa3@8Keusqj~y@}kU#wxTSY9@$bTKb zbi7m6R`{`Vu=Dvmdl8$kr6q&C4tw2`N!g*A7=X%0_v@wW%Der}w(XF%VjRxPCtgW@ zseK_X>{_p##)|5tr)m*WvrV(T!HJXKCyHQ`l5X4e0>Y^0_ANc#do#7`zwC^H4eZ?N z%ZtVf+e;M~Pg@vuTn%f5JMKJ*oOR#Fsd?_>XT{w~7usCw94qQn>hqZu%?0~|9_o*$ zq-)-_P-*-MjNJIF@EBB$53l{(f3!p|j)o8MUD$~<a{k$m6&c3QSI{=Ejcip|7d2M7 zPXF<*%roMu8|729KuS0K%slWx-JRSvZk_SSL-6qS_}ElOp=&g`{9yhi-LjMH(*FFb zSWb$!oaNmqOGFhl&mS_Nn_RrSgWbO?vh;-*>7q(b8Z8VG+;Y*k5U6=S-*H#ePO-!= zt4lTPZ(PpyKN`pBovj}F6q^vbPn>eZ!DDy<<N*z1rx4Pna&vfi%<9yLH!2X(*R2_f zvr;N)7ro0HJ}O{arSN5`)+Eu!bIcek|Mxv7l(f}3<bi5a<QFf!k7bFdkNb+17@2tM zio+G84>NSBc>Jzmn^&U~>3T&-THM6;+N>r|??pw$+oeK)S#8nsux#dYLTlFnA}>gF z@O%aT?JnurDcJc*h&T#?u!_&k+c9P!n6P8`78oN@PCe0i0{`PdTxsBg8A|v8YqUf6 ztnhSKuF5a-3q@*X$*&Ck^cHh9*Ed#3P3k=xBR=fU39|`o8ZE5JZ5pG`l0nyN))cN+ zmb)}>s4y<+<`dFH$Ez;CvXWDprX!AFHLv$-i&u&_!7R>nxc2g!!3KeK>e%U5Cd%H* z`ocG2zL>h}a`8d>#lF;%VQmzak2^SIznRLqcdl(ZB8l}(Rqw=49LKVj_$sk!I+MxI zn5)^Z<Nda#DmpxAS|{e?nQL`edH^3v7_z(0`l&0Yh!x&9!lv5$xddc%PMqcxK$VQ& zNWxP1--pcRg1eW;6Ly>K$>O_OY}|HBcBie^Jy>0Rn^9z+Z8<T9rP%Y5bnc4ua0<Ow zs78H&S#hx~GtE?-6(5^;VFYPeq<0XzKUi6x969S=uGSkxO&1&<2~QOU&WI{6I4$ir z+^TpY&~4y(XOPF3$L6I3(XAA_uKTnJW#xJ@Ty@0PMheX}sHEz%mefMRE?2hnvMSre zl;fQEE2%<u_#e`Pqo_Cw)D;eW_wmu|vgA?eqt@(x$?ae(Q<H&sk7cb^!``FsH=vI! zFUqEj%MzKe*9z&J5avELpH(cMv6KvjT|e{>s=jZGi(M9cpbEwA5WZ#AHKn^A7g6Cy zmDkwB`pq?lBE~->{M`1|bK#u(8Mh<xk30)nQ@xg$xo`d3c>Z3>e4p3V3c457nHf5S ziZl-o`JrUXqBPwAJpZJUAd?&*SCGc|jsC2%*1+<>&OYH2^OtVOJe$vN_T>8y_7^>W z-(M|MJUJ=iu46<<a_YRZCkGpC!Wpn=pG)e-d+~?t5!DZw&RhItLF>p-o)Q})auiyp zp!vbpx-Yl3@)|M8?kZ(xXthQSUbm_zFNWHZ$EFAF?TcI-lPzd1mvhhgl;ljbAZLfc z*_mAPJkQ3y5<0fLc0<;1z53NOFNTVss6AjrtHD2Wz(BBT(*VcI<QO2L#lqQU)Ck9T z$=M&0c$Gz0!>ZqqHFbaQf19!+T{0rNAyaJ$dgxkSv2gcaTN;LW@6D4Oh1v_#=jZ#3 zv`#dHHU0Qv&n7;K9;(uuRV1TDf8Xp=f|7`@mOA@-)k^st)_OPJ%)P4ek-X9~9k-KC zXuK|70t}qj6G_hf!r&9CTUWME@@N+-FH=D5$_u+H;|;}y3}bq@pPueQXc)e!=hC2X z<-2$6Wev~xwAgG@y-nG_C?VwWKvlBRkq~7ph`|5=l&#GEK@O8mW}CwhfCT=0NFEaL zZ2%!G0b0cXG(<qJW;i1De=rDKt%K0GHF*#gB7D=qe=P=}uXL3ejRn!GmwaUy%o-gQ zv(`%hSC>QM00{qgFZ{JLh{K>)2YzL10zn)OyE+iW5!bW>A#kl10tx?Z{8wQR!Vz?E zf4}C>V<3nCW`ByXhXFF#38XlYoFEdO1Y#)!G|h<!kf>BA5*bgR*dun5{+|RHgs^pr z45b`kg>s@}xky_anT972NJIie!x70e9GO6&kjW5@KqX-@0FH#Pw?{<B?2C#y9Hqeu RLx2zwz$47esO~hxe*l`fmHq$# diff --git a/fig/compare_class_C.pdf b/fig/compare_class_C.pdf index 019dad9803c8d3d483b12a2b6be309700d87c4df..805353c39818cc9c43b1d83409e9411174676cf1 100644 GIT binary patch delta 2235 zcmaiwdpMMN8^^<TFs+D~m@MU(VP~Faj!(^q88a;^nHV{3F^xkx8&nP>>s2wu^hATS z4i&SS2E&j->437N9T}CpOe#q^y_Hs4?R&j@UFnba_t$-We&754e((FWLTyB$ma~nY zjUs*D)GZaoF1cFTymYO`K2o9jl?&d*M~mx;c4-6ZzgzHI%rE2%nSP1a4%mieJtdhl zsP3TnBzAt?JW7AwP|7q`eNah<-Y2M9X2w^qF&|8x|B%>_xNb@3+R53rEp2=3TaP_Z z)l03Gx}b5Ra1Bh|NHTunJgYgVu5HHG($gN)d$nW0ZTZ}sL#u}N?2Y!D*&ja7jc6o? zmj41BDVRSvho?|h{fhZm!Cb4I3Tq@Q$~?F7rVj0XLRH(AJy>6%2)sYJN=0d|vmPv) zGl<3PZ3V)T9#CzR5-OHz^PA*H!S3uD)OKCVcwr3Hrk`^y3<EeD`O_{r%--XxEluqz z)!CIA#Y4fZ8`3g3jTG1WlOYLf3GtiV_8rugp}G}COJb^uQg6|ss(mM{uU{Llb-tnX zn^|4eS)FZ2zm5=ve-!-PbWx<Xx^0}AFl1#%_z9PxUY7*4O}bYl@5w2aNW82sRIjyC z819=gv4$*6{sGD@*`986Cd!{*w;aDEn3J^ZGq%#vFRJ?{m~_`|tI>#4vtX*Fvh7?3 zKO^$(g!kqy>0rtT{ohv2_9gjmHOzgu#>!01>9wBEtLc3^tDJLcnmpC||4fU$_1c5Q z`?KFL7_}Fzs$Flp|I?}1d33cqroAFERbxDQ7+3pKJ#9Jpa>SZZW=LQdfA@VxqyD2m z)?Y1_@yu%74eH<5D7_o?3p&04^o)zEW>UPF5&cTp;L)_)u^jsipAo0pNDk^1T;%Y? zcmouKjJe*cJU{sZ!0~R-WUGv?+YSW}5tR;w5#DUwrvfeilszQ~E2w3n9Vp(fexL&E zvt_*FGv&HwFX-hx{7X%~@fL4BR|Vx!x()|<pt)x&^pn9#b{U$vrsJwDcOSZF5}8*1 zx}5TM#jzulfa5!qJ7+y}B&UTnL1k#&UkIL-wx_&0o6^EA;OxtMQ``k-CL3OI9mm?o zx~iCDWZ;224)-P~<d31Ps&Zl5H0Pn>W}0>5%ZYAGsTaeVfBsBQZWg1p<6>@@M6si( z=bA1eG_@s^{UY<(D9fXro&7k!eiM3A3EQuLz+wy!^3c6Tqk{T>IW%N#yqxnK@V{si zSck7XC;TK4r~4F1h;-q^d&i29hd%|+NgC2KCu{t!+}7Q0XmGB#6{_1-y5j7*Xifno z#pn<P6(W-J?W@xr$}2h>KAG2e&XnF%di)&htntY_U)<+{YS~lEg0-Aau|^K()v9+H z8TPwem3Ta(qr2FKR<4cDE(*dfG_l!JJ>zb@h1RY;5_3u0xaDDQKEwH$Frhc&uI_Bp zgSy=K?$Tkaf#!g^Bb;zEST-RSzUwL*ele|+RQEeSGe^o<`fx?=5m$Y?V4am2=TxmI z&mAs9;ZyVHXXb}@BmCq#9{C;7#u4>4RWmBKV#G4G$fh#{Q!(|Lt(3Z=itW~qX6jkn zIKAn+Z6&H0qvl#jk5h{LFzNFrKQ#uP6#Z)b2g_f8&(GA(Xadg}%xp?-ceNXnNgtev zv@hk;5+t<oV<z$<OsMF<MkICE-&oHx+$a0;yQNb=`Nx-gOsv@YJd+O*n)Q7H?e7!1 zEO_13Sx(Clu6{bjWk*vu5$6SAwb!DiJ63c$R6Pm^tyZz}YM!6C)y}*(a^B~@ye0&l zNWAp1F#1kscb;l!gG|@|P;I%(jUeBrv9D(NSmR42>K5ZY*)yv$Thv9m`fs#-^rY`& zAzxm>tA@zxV`7ueeNtEY?MBb(r?0j3T*5?8ukUP%bMNfE>s2cto-lanV?x_}M@+5r zK{m1^iX0%(X4XDVYo*viB{#U8C&<fcMtOKS8We)!tTT$!qrSUXyDa1W!xMX#B=zz4 z>O2M;(ZgBc`O3KJTXMmh4QM&Hk$YHdCkr?12+xnW7|3BJ^ys5-VzUCJC_3@cF@>l< zo^b2Vwn6jL7j;U^3YDV%-aPjK_Ugx=eC1JP-sp>s3nMa0pX32WM6sR5z~%jqz|R^O zw%d9HH)3BbFNPZs{-ufx+z)SErlkhLp35k*4~DyqzbBevO&2hNgeQ^VRY(BNCgs5G zNHdueIb021ZHR$~pfb3`&`Ty<7OeyCBx!z!2S`NNp9I2NkjG&YvW096X{iQRLs;0s zFhG{RNp7<eTA0ehFma{;UdG@Cs4pi1Sda)1VM#EgPKMx@!B%|G6#M0wMwlZ0E*AcA ziy0Omg1ALGECi4jQh(Kpg+MIn8-~Y{zhNW@_%GxCV+>%iIKm<!fCr()0|7h^SXk^U zV*pP8zU?K0i;V#S7W;KCABzR?5b<mHH~U}0e*%I809tGU5{THvR{#lQ^5P4E1PF&; z6dGJODzN4ohy%%RaVV7!60s13CpZ#tOaQ>+X*ePY#1j^FqB$)jCgbf9l>aL+^+#Zw zB02OBF6TgOT(~KQz@*aw28oWR(TF%Eod!7)2qYo{B9Mt#97J$L*xMswc>yuJgE}$X RAOuJx5O4?!3x*pL@fW4(p%4H7 delta 2225 zcmaiwc{r5)8pn+mXC_%PO=@&Zh0%n0W_xBvc4me`rLr$sCd(|0ElNEqUZQ%dhm??z zvSpdc@+vt(Q5u9oDx#D|mWsT|@xJF==ep7#=l9p|`dpv;{@(XJ(uMfgg*aym1#8e1 z?@CKAg~etj&0)&a>mxJdYp#1_CuCQFtL1CW!dhMtZQ2s3ImY72%@18ASF?2ApX$62 z6#IiS<5fCwb+Ygo>FcY7@gGso7Ixm-Xl6duCjGP!K9i<Y|5^1<uOA<vZ*s=2X~e5i zREp!lE`RO=n7NH(XPPxZ*-Z(hKzpWzM!n)coRo977tOpunrd>kA3FWHUwQT&XZ*aW z{*R4av+qWHXQJMl$mVVy9^DlSFEbu}S%}Dt8OI!w%Doxs$D{@+&J7&Mc<}p%5x10A zKL1>9t3K3>AILc&Frw=d3ia0+I44(Nb&zTa`mMKb`X$I*k?yBh4k9FPMJx1)s4GXM zpnK3bMJ%WSs#5v$X$O&ixG0Kt`(o{0Ab~M3`v_wA!1IPYWHlphwH^ux#)5$&%P^xn zS=@n2K5q4f2ywN|iEqtS9K^-!-aRc<!y8zrM@6Z^$bHV9C7tI-x?gVqy`yP`f+FQC zd4-By#tCE%HS^|<`o5=7#=C&iM<+Ddv_wK~R_*osd&jW_srP3)TOm(F<1b#d#7|}Z zmvXrC(^X#I$g{^6Oou{V8CpyF4JV>>UR%|i8LpAFv#5NZeS(qmPA6`R^Jb1H^)>y& zc6p`x@vh+VvHr3>#D_P7W0%Q9k(BTXVZ0JhEVS)8)2<~g%f^pEjsd$i`I`HWu>*2P zBVEAlZdDdyi*@0Z!gx<^v>acTEV(h(X05p=MD0R9-Aw-G$aC*$S#|XJNTvDi=XsN< zfNyU#(h++&zU`5;Sx|P|zPF;p@6P&KU8~q3U#Q)@CebuAa`t5tuPN3wCFv*?jo?*o zmin-JFk5P4YOJB}eYGRjLxajZ=N8#xFgIx18_z-Z!sAv!__gybQwDD9UEFHxEGN(_ zQ{Tbzq;pREj<yXbO}w9gJIwpeUbjYpmsHPi@hm4VBH5hg{ff&{kEHkne!xZ-tYXpW z`Ri5r$`TuCrg(Pw;McuUS&f*+4YL5YsN^O`$qLP(HbcFX1jEMlw_e&~o|u#r7MFzT zYt8MC(oIocMaMsSx-)1Ex7WbQLd#%ZLRU3!Y|0LEtb0}b=50LbC!2%n%K}O^wFwR% zSUXkJ<or3hY1$#!`pl84tgMy>qRO>)AFeFgb98m@q>TsTA*Mu5&sFb?hp@+G`B_O+ zzMatY3-lt3Q_xub)!DP5d1!{E_2qTU@OSg1;zo-j;qaA)X?|cfktjCc6`7<Gl^lXp zxUj=uRHZ~-iMn_gj>6Wi#FGrSi~|1qt?67p!A1?g?oD^G`zLiWi$@*rUX&4<@7Q{c zu8A1-5Y<(%JWJC{N^-+=hiyu~?x%P4fE6Hw?{)0?mkYWfX8Z)vzRz!%GqAkq^a+SK zHliq6|KULkv-Os3OHIe0;?4(Z0b4_YEVIeEZ{l8f6UuOunhtkPoJh8UAhnNw<K8!M zdy}Y170o659yU3k6FMN;F`X1a&(K$?8SgFK_BK&;Do2m|B(Vh@1bj@Llw>}eyhea- zKlX=`i1#j7Ssc>87MZ8)CQVa+%YSr>6O-qgbH`rR(OqX&H?*&I?pdkY-W3A|G2-|s z3Ui8%IE(*0SDwt8LAqt^%)Y|8?Z|f2E4`aQR<u+tK3RTS@vTE8dA`}luc-p-jxW<+ zDQOA;i$Cw*?)$dxsdjl$d85|@qZ{?m*s{5L^U?XJir+3=4tF(e$Ls!BTYpKn1?o&k zA9L@Hw&Ii~)6XP2$zAI3Tz4+Nqa=M-;E{seiTBMEehU?^BKd<*&K=3t)_QR5wp5{p zVD#8zet}YA6ZUC{&Bzsr-G`(R?6W9hYOo{&_cA-3FLtiCv2(E@yq?{%ejz0tio3V( z`R=-wi^<v=16tpk*4Xn2o<2wpJpxf42UpT=rtM(#PaSt}2s}u@i2CNy$&3QkbmvA9 zXUAEU%4zgYhFt+F580TH(oPF;7gsNq(jv^t<DO!Q8rM9Dv@VZTyFyc2#o)Bk+c76w zr`i?<tDP|@uFx+mJe2D#fSD`N2qtX5(nuVD7pW+MH~<&y6NI9Y=pa14g#@cJPQj&G zTg1%_9RzHuLxeR9y<t_nlQ?Om^TyRA(tmwAmCk_Q(#f!<);ahZLtEUbB|yL*nE))* z$rT?ptR$==Q5RhYBAbF^icPrQ@(NTkg#yq>aK1lNo(aN({&<Lq1O9qAArAHThYXS^ zOBp}{DZmmBpfQ-gGUi|7{nQTtNdWB^wz%wn81%nj0HiUOiX<utTpF^-7~~}lNmL5s z*IGKbbP*D5ah0EHc>qABGU-3VzZsM9leoxeWMFA9nYMVYUpxk5X)u|_q>^A!pxWAB zx`Gr64Za*`43Stgb0!lcQ^*!1DtmEwI%r9;qB8(0i$!6OtxQlx|5w3zpomt%zLo)8 zUtU;*07qm{EdaU|1vICyEJ<uj8k<R_G05gj3mS`RNn+7aCMKw`aPQFYD3ws|K@=IJ NfdEQdo3)FL`ZsNVo)`cC diff --git a/paper.tex b/paper.tex index bcbfb5d..61d95c6 100644 --- a/paper.tex +++ b/paper.tex @@ -157,7 +157,7 @@ To maintain the performance of the parallel program , they set the processor with the biggest load to the highest gear and then compute the scaling factor values for the rest of the processors. Although this model was built for parallel architectures, it can be adapted to distributed architectures by taking into account the communications. The primary contribution of this paper is presenting a new online scaling factor selection method which has the following characteristics : \begin{enumerate} -\item Based on Rauber's analytical model to predict the energy consumption and the execution time of the application with different frequency gears. +\item Based on Rauber and Rünger analytical model to predict the energy consumption and the execution time of the application with different frequency gears. \item Selects the frequency scaling factor for simultaneously optimizing energy reduction and maintaining performance. \item Well adapted to distributed architectures because it takes into account the communication time. \item Well adapted to distributed applications with imbalanced tasks. @@ -241,7 +241,7 @@ new frequency value~(\emph {P-state}) in the governor. The CPU governor is an interface driver supplied by the operating system's kernel to lower a core's frequency. This factor reduces quadratically the dynamic power which may cause degradation in performance and thus, the increase of the static energy because the execution time is increased~\cite{36}. If the tasks are sorted according to their execution times before scaling in a descending order, the total energy consumption model for a parallel -homogeneous platform, as presented by Rauber et al.~\cite{3}, can be written as a function of the scaling factor \emph S, as in EQ~(\ref{eq:energy}). +homogeneous platform, as presented by Rauber and Rünger~\cite{3}, can be written as a function of the scaling factor \emph S, as in EQ~(\ref{eq:energy}). \begin{equation} \label{eq:energy} @@ -494,7 +494,7 @@ respectively. Depending on EQ~(\ref{eq:energy}), we measure the energy consumption for all the NAS MPI programs while assuming the power dynamic with the highest frequency is equal to \np[W]{20} and the power static is equal to \np[W]{4} for all experiments. These power values were also -used by Rauber and Rünger in~\cite{3}. The results showed that the algorithm selected +used by Rauber and Rünger in~\cite{3}. The results showed that the algorithm selected different scaling factors for each program depending on the communication features of the program as in the plots~(\ref{fig:nas}). These plots illustrate that there are different distances between the normalized energy and the normalized @@ -710,8 +710,8 @@ In the near future, we would like to adapt this scaling factor selection method \section*{Acknowledgment} -\AG{Jean-Claude, why did you remove the Mésocentre here?} -As a PhD student, M. Ahmed Fanfakh, would like to thank the University of +Computations have been performed on the supercomputer facilities of the +Mésocentre de calcul de Franche-Comté. As a PhD student, M. Ahmed Fanfakh, would like to thank the University of Babylon (Iraq) for supporting his work. % trigger a \newpage just before the given reference -- 2.39.5