From b06b270b9964583f76b38ef50528eb6e00a6881b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: afanfakh Date: Wed, 3 Dec 2014 10:50:10 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] adding comparison section --- Heter_paper.tex | 93 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-------- fig/compare_EDP.pdf | Bin 0 -> 17668 bytes fig/sen_comp.pdf | Bin 17563 -> 17564 bytes fig/three_scenarios.pdf | Bin 14943 -> 13526 bytes my_reference.bib | 2 +- 5 files changed, 76 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-) create mode 100644 fig/compare_EDP.pdf diff --git a/Heter_paper.tex b/Heter_paper.tex index f34524c..d318912 100644 --- a/Heter_paper.tex +++ b/Heter_paper.tex @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ \usepackage{algorithm} \usepackage{subfig} \usepackage{amsmath} - +\usepackage{multirow} \usepackage{url} \DeclareUrlCommand\email{\urlstyle{same}} @@ -207,7 +207,7 @@ task which have the highest computation time and no slack time. \begin{figure}[t] \centering - \includegraphics[scale=0.6]{fig/commtasks} + \includegraphics[scale=0.5]{fig/commtasks} \caption{Parallel tasks on a heterogeneous platform} \label{fig:heter} \end{figure} @@ -266,7 +266,7 @@ by the number of iterations of that application. This prediction model is developed from the model for predicting the execution time of message passing distributed applications for homogeneous architectures~\cite{Our_first_paper}. -The execution time prediction model is used in the method for optimizing both +The execution time prediction model is uSpiliopoulossed in the method for optimizing both energy consumption and performance of iterative methods, which is presented in the following sections. @@ -670,16 +670,16 @@ Finally, These nodes were connected via an ethernet network with 1 Gbit/s bandwi & & GHz & GHz &GHz & & \\ \hline 1 &40 & 2.5 & 1.2 & 0.1 & 20~w &4~w \\ - & & & & & & \\ + \hline 2 &50 & 2.66 & 1.6 & 0.133 & 25~w &5~w \\ - & & & & & & \\ + \hline 3 &60 & 2.9 & 1.2 & 0.1 & 30~w &6~w \\ - & & & & & & \\ + \hline 4 &70 & 3.4 & 1.6 & 0.133 & 35~w &7~w \\ - & & & & & & \\ + \hline \end{tabular} \label{table:platform} @@ -708,7 +708,7 @@ The other benchmarks such as BT and SP should be executed on $1, 4, 9, 16, 36, 6 \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{7}{l|}} \hline - Method & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & time/s & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG & 64.64 & 3560.39 &34.16 &6.72 &27.44 \\ @@ -735,7 +735,7 @@ The other benchmarks such as BT and SP should be executed on $1, 4, 9, 16, 36, 6 \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{7}{l|}} \hline - Method & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & time/s & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &36.11 &3263.49 &31.25 &7.12 &24.13 \\ @@ -762,7 +762,7 @@ The other benchmarks such as BT and SP should be executed on $1, 4, 9, 16, 36, 6 \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{7}{l|}} \hline - Method & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & time/s & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &31.74 &4373.90 &26.29 &9.57 &16.72 \\ @@ -789,7 +789,7 @@ The other benchmarks such as BT and SP should be executed on $1, 4, 9, 16, 36, 6 \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{7}{l|}} \hline - Method & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & time/s & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &32.35 &6704.21 &16.15 &5.30 &10.85 \\ @@ -816,7 +816,7 @@ The other benchmarks such as BT and SP should be executed on $1, 4, 9, 16, 36, 6 \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{7}{l|}} \hline - Method & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & time/s & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &46.65 &17521.83 &8.13 &1.68 &6.45 \\ @@ -844,7 +844,7 @@ The other benchmarks such as BT and SP should be executed on $1, 4, 9, 16, 36, 6 \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{7}{l|}} \hline - Method & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Execution & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & time/s & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &56.92 &41163.36 &4.00 &1.10 &2.90 \\ @@ -964,7 +964,7 @@ results in less energy saving but less performance degradation. \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{6}{l|}} \hline - Method & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &4144.21 &22.42 &7.72 &14.70 \\ @@ -993,7 +993,7 @@ results in less energy saving but less performance degradation. \centering \begin{tabular}{|*{6}{l|}} \hline - Method & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ + Program & Energy & Energy & Performance & Distance \\ name & consumption/J & saving\% & degradation\% & \\ \hline CG &2812.38 &36.36 &6.80 &29.56 \\ @@ -1017,11 +1017,11 @@ results in less energy saving but less performance degradation. \begin{figure} \centering - \subfloat[Comparison the average of the results on 8 nodes]{% - \includegraphics[width=.33\textwidth]{fig/sen_comp}\label{fig:sen_comp}}% + \subfloat[Comparison of the results on 8 nodes]{% + \includegraphics[width=.30\textwidth]{fig/sen_comp}\label{fig:sen_comp}}% \subfloat[Comparison the selected frequency scaling factors of MG benchmark class C running on 8 nodes]{% - \includegraphics[width=.33\textwidth]{fig/three_scenarios}\label{fig:scales_comp}} + \includegraphics[width=.34\textwidth]{fig/three_scenarios}\label{fig:scales_comp}} \label{fig:comp} \caption{The comparison of the three power scenarios} \end{figure} @@ -1029,6 +1029,59 @@ results in less energy saving but less performance degradation. +\subsection{The comparison of the proposed scaling algorithm } +\label{sec.compare_EDP} + +In this section, we compare our scaling factors selection algorithm +with Spiliopoulos et al. algorithm \cite{Spiliopoulos_Green.governors.Adaptive.DVFS}. +They developed an online frequency selecting algorithm running over multicore architecture. +The algorithm predicted both the energy and performance during the runtime of the program, then +selecting the frequencies that minimized the energy and delay products (EDP), $EDP=Enegry * Delay$. +To be able to compare with this algorithm, we used our energy and execution time models in prediction process, +equations (\ref{eq:energy}) and (\ref{eq:fnew}). Also their algorithm is adapted to taking into account +the heterogeneous platform to starts selecting the +initial frequencies using the equation (\ref{eq:Fint}). The algorithm built to test all possible frequencies as +a brute-force search algorithm. + +The comparison results of running NAS benchmarks class C on 8 or 9 nodes are +presented in table \ref{table:compare_EDP}. The results show that our algorithm has a biggest energy saving percentage, +on average it has 29.76\% and thier algorithm has 25.75\%, +while the average of performance degradation percentage is approximately the same, the average for our algorithm is +equal to 3.89\% and for their algorithm is equal to 4.03\%. In general, our algorithm outperforms +Spiliopoulos et al. algorithm in term of energy and performance tradeoff see figure (\ref{fig:compare_EDP}). +This because our algorithm maximized the difference (the distance) between the energy saving and the performance degradation +comparing to their EDP optimization function. It is also keeps the frequency of the slowest node without change +that gave some enhancements to the energy and performance tradeoff. + + +\begin{table}[h] + \caption{Comparing the proposed algorithm} + \centering +\begin{tabular}{|l|l|l|l|l|l|l|l|} +\hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{\multirow{2}{*}{\begin{tabular}[c]{@{}l@{}}Program \\ name\end{tabular}}} & \multicolumn{2}{l|}{Energy saving \%} & \multicolumn{2}{l|}{Perf. degradation \%} & \multicolumn{2}{l|}{Distance} \\ \cline{3-8} +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{} & EDP & MaxDist & EDP & MaxDist & EDP & MaxDist \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{CG} & 27.58 & 31.25 & 5.82 & 7.12 & 21.76 & 24.13 \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{MG} & 29.49 & 33.78 & 3.74 & 6.41 & 25.75 & 27.37 \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{LU} & 19.55 & 28.33 & 0.0 & 0.01 & 19.55 & 28.22 \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{EP} & 28.40 & 27.04 & 4.29 & 0.49 & 24.11 & 26.55 \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{BT} & 27.68 & 32.32 & 6.45 & 7.87 & 21.23 & 24.43 \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{SP} & 20.52 & 24.73 & 5.21 & 2.78 & 15.31 & 21.95 \\ \hline +\multicolumn{2}{|l|}{FT} & 27.03 & 31.02 & 2.75 & 2.54 & 24.28 & 28.48 \\ \hline + +\end{tabular} +\label{table:compare_EDP} +\end{table} + + + +\begin{figure}[t] + \centering + \includegraphics[scale=0.6]{fig/compare_EDP.pdf} + \caption{Tradeoff comparison for NAS benchmarks class C} + \label{fig:compare_EDP} +\end{figure} + \section{Conclusion} \label{sec.concl} @@ -1044,6 +1097,10 @@ known in advance and depends on the global convergence of the iterative system. \section*{Acknowledgment} +This work has been partially supported by the Labex +ACTION project (contract “ANR-11-LABX-01-01”). As a PhD student, +Mr. Ahmed Fanfakh, would like to thank the University of +Babylon (Iraq) for supporting his work. % trigger a \newpage just before the given reference diff --git a/fig/compare_EDP.pdf b/fig/compare_EDP.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1aaef32784aa33acf2d183e082a98e9db5f49192 GIT binary patch literal 17668 zcmai+1ymi&vao~0MuWQshp;#9?(Q1g-Q9u*ch}$$T!Rzb-8~T8-2(h@uAOt-u8qG7Rzc8cL`MoQY`rf1~C46d0#d*#WQv?{K-}#qj6TJ^M&)p)*;24e2i1dRlO& z&8@vLdiC%-)Y_x_7Q*K2lQ>B%86NYIaxt#;HcQwfZbmsiL_bB8!bT*dSrJ3;mJtj? z>Dm1jw9!wo6xGSBto?Z+Q~z8bq{X`yJ3Ka^`Mp9`0!!}-6U0K$^4{L_yPFLfI1nV* zQP;J`LQ%L@_zzZ_7v@u?uMV-z2Z7eoN@}I17alN$v-Yk!r=5`Ud)fTgdPEh49X!cD zcvnOttn{jo=SARGmYz+|;;y8=fDb1(b0R~N6Ev)370b|BBj?;KZn#rl^Z>E?a;GFS zv;>r!zdo43>7C(Lq{ip+r@vQDgVsf1CRL4x$$1h#Z$+oqglmYJWga2oLLe(fgc-h6 ztfMQ%_n`XX52_aB$vLF!e$@%%`~m`>?7?<_x4>Z@%t#Lwjx@^&U5v?ttfuF+!$bns zltedpn;;CbrCQcI^VkQ=BvqC!f!s#s89+)6$W`C#24234I8d@sFJE9E!i`|vwI{NM zmS+`dSjwaQ6Vxn#)0Y1(&E*~=@IstXZ* zo(1KJ9%2mgI?9R|8eE^H4fO^lgbi0?-h2Z+>1YCu`O;YyvQoc3bCWOKQkQ?{(E`I& zt^(iUb5ChO`Yg@Ccasmy;qx-s%U@-Es?1utuBhDYicE% z-V^rNTI$+Uh8bc94`1AYlj=GAL9ro+Yt{d!?ZNlN7Z&~f#^76oA3C~(pM9co7@2-u zZk2p*Eiy!&$CWRaQBRtp*B{JKnTGpdT#_;Si|YUfb6&EGkz=@2`rDX>tdR=~6P?VY zPqIjbtOl#8U(6|=ff+sA=;#E$NyYcHJeHIV>SK>!3gd=-=@|ZH`XSLs>VlL3_7l0$aJZG!$3^TjRk!yP&{l?cR<#3Nm<<|q zi>Q!-sM4t5*k%K=a+oRZPCBR*0u+$a)6-wMR`=ayPz93)uOWn!>xK`63E zYbdCVmEVDA8{x3AEvir+^V{FYe1lNZqhrzzwOh<*Ax@t+(E^=%VN)F*ywLlSzyug4-Q4T@8t~Wz_fP z1$FVyDlU)J9Zxy-Zi(~v;qC&yM$50U3pV-6^+O1?cPeakXa_$Np&0PO;0GhOZN5{U zNiqi<4dkN&8~nd(c_*If)~ftbc! z)hGl(-+-Gu7+ZrTHB!Ex4RKpk`oE+1*dIbS{piggon>U3!#cVi_2dc-5wp~%vtOX<|yeDa@$ZIRFH&$>|+UkP3#5+k-MK-QXOgkzU{4{`sa{hu_Usz$r+C zzsa@;E?gUs>c&-oknrs!Cm}E4;sZHr*miL%v2Iyy*w04G@=fd$D;pR$x$=4;1YOk) zD8R^4f-JWa9cBv2T*38hnEnd+T+k}sgXlrCh2MIytd?Q%j!iecOD?PF|PguEd}p8%>o=-a4>@8!9k`IbFgth}vLG`Qtt zdG_{Xew=4O3yTm9!!5owW26>W*T6_^Z#S0__1oNFJH^YX8{nWrxVKJcr*7gbsEjOZQ2k`=&(PSx zeQj0s(cq+;SYSF!Wxpm2@7gvZa%G^Krc82|1;XKrS%bP5Dq4?56jG2XWckkZRk;2b zw2hxeqwHt#uS%j3l439Yds{U)kPE1&y&9@|LiaNohs_4Qcn?#b{nTTKDjLO-+v|Dg z=D~?Q4K0<~4xBm>Y_aGRe9LRR^g~!sWE)iFDkxRHRdf_+r=q4~%2vSTRh%r8RpnJA zNn##~He2M;$m`7Q+{6#C_}JH}Gj|*a_7>+Qp%%^Xe_A{cUGh{73i{}Xd{n1m(6We{ z#HHuQRd(Etglo3(btRm5ELR*MK5gzM7}HY7(e!a7g>({ZC~CB{B_OhX72g$KU3lS8>0+DtV>bu_}Cnuk+r8#hA zS+3Dmle~w& zTASf~9VrI|!!l=Mi82Rnr^1;S-%dYSIeY4(bw{b*Tn-e|O}DLxH6DL))*1g&U(ojH zYcPUC_B|mD?R%Du;JE{TFL9IEJk{1bcjZ1VP0nSxu4ToQ$t9lzJ;iC2RZtq7;W4F% zn;Mn6U^Th~7wNIQYb$0$YrF-0MChq({12TD`j^*@HSA^~C`hXf*(+Gz%dj;w93P>rzB=R4MQa$1nYef57OYK~rhTCPr;b%CX$s3bBQMYqX z;;Br3FB`UEj%M?+K9_%zB)P1iR{CyC(=r`Zo5UHppobpOL**fDQX7iFK`AC&5zaNB z{j0*kjwJdcoQk#!M-sAX6Mo??~u|<+~}>>LXmgAQc7t`shqyC{z<89XCrD32p2# z1x1o6LI}a40%EdH+A1swttE!R!*Dc&PF9zsgY%sp_EkJt86U5M>X6E4VxlEWlegmPnpI2mD}dfn()7b`SJb|i z53M3y#)<)Tq6YY=tWtMrftBKSK=~L5R2>@YBo_&3GV(6|ocOcK_Lws$I6nGJa9oqh zK)lbv%9EfL;oNCCiQWAxGE{f*F3S%`UzNYBzt@X7n@5F)(n&refm3?!VfZ-*_r5GJ zJ1p#7nxQhv8lJH%RJ93p>B+}XKof;|E~>A9b6*Z91wGeeOH_oIYK7~g{`~-XDF(K) za96Za3AWLkv_0S}w20h(PsT zMM5z#JU9)W^t9$fxw>rS4}o#LE8H+0TJ&E=uHY>8h|knEXFJ!F0RYSo{3%k3n`My6 zw75G-ftxr5Op+=VJb5N%(j@WL!?F^iofP6cN%;sFX>pu+b#c@(H6QFuf`L5=`4ZB= zQqofq<={YJUXCDrSiF0r)8-19+1~x@^V09%*-x}u<28;nwd6@z#ztd?!{aM_dp}TM zBoE^_;+c*+RgASiqc&bYBnz7AC`eRKCuEy40r%IfLwk8VVK=jcrnf(+uIBei7k$Zy zkpOkO6~BB`Q|PB>YghV}k27Vk6k0ntzcOdJnymM1GJxay z`iQm(g&rX*+T;;45pyRS{>%0Xr`5JKWl%LTA!X6LRa#wSJ#tsxtNE`GXE#c=Q(EN~$ja>%af4SraTEk)JXTm39Qr$YY^ASJ8`feZ9(xo4@ zrGad6mjYw9qsi;05lVa}3?5k|&`U%iRd#HoRoNj|u?A!eZz@kF9oG&!YJ!X?@gf_T z4+z1`61J~CGFK1lq}Mh%AW;Qw895gf+gp4Q-M0U*Wu#$SA}6a#>Fy?q2%x$+9?rW+ zET(ZF<$8@sdM62D8HZk0KtL_KVeb>)I_7=)fbBrxu`RDW#{J$87&6oIG7C8s=*zw- zEFyIju%I0)_L)W-pdx3RL#V?{fky>24_YkFb`Bv&ubGVILFjFN{GHq3jBEns4#%bV z+QOYVhi7R$@8}Yaw(yoyGzigi>bJS)bPBCGJN;u0ky7g7hVyW8|?EKtX3eIxfb zRNHp!`&MU{@mB8Nduc=-@ZZaCZmcu$e3|L*VV@_a(eH_*NPmyq2Mxy7OGHuNBA1|? z+6H7=Y$h}oU#C=g5QINjs+SoaADOsdJu(j`?yEDkBxrXNn#fg`GD3L=^Nc%~t+VA2xWO)gs7(yP3Lug25Q5=1A2+Qz$qTR)qulkeZOMhi{B%GnIuqi&%VT(ES-c zEAW1rd+?XmJ>iDOm)(lS6g}rkdQ7_b?iZc9v@|vWb({ z<4!U134l=;S0HAmdztT*>PWsW87803sC#HvEyyv^x%~c)Mv0tYy!Ab-Q82m zCcAN*bH_>yGdMNGoH&sf$>>oc(dy%CLToT)C#NJ9g=6SzYZ*xleCWA`g5M!yRI)&{9ZVedyu3jri@b?B6qR zs?@OFQPpS=Hsh`hMMGIy1tE$_z=;$Xe|W)kbU*5 zyWwy^r+MU)I;ib?AwTdSsP%#zkJ1s?LUe;4U225aZHL<{>))h~q|bvCQC-GR+K(-1 z$kM%8ZU`?zHD>-ro z6qExKv=RMWAq=90WsH;>s?tnqK(aX@smGZjNuh`-IdsQQ;V6@wl&w9yFBm5tXS1{4 zqLJpuy*KLp)+Wm@NwW*tu@aJ4Fj5sW;7t=hCMXV$`w-l3+I4G(RPT?3uwUP&rR|bs z``-27{SXw}i|i-7zxOC|d>Sv|E9LKB+=#}%>Xb0T>A1t4na%ALJd_ClwfUqic1dFt z3Vy$PFY~^)AHkBv-QBAqsHAq57 z`Lxw}ka9<>+YZ9?4PslAv&M3EGVLNZ$i#y#rF)b_4`*vhb!KD?hZtv?&ug@m^6x@RkS*=>_-`@58-3LKZZZ^w@kijo&n zt{h`cYa}gBIm&vvRUe*M7b->QYhng59P9B7O@~sTgMYe@zSBosh#oh9HpKXfBtFqM zF9aRAr7l`9wSgiTfDu@FVogo*UMS{!r*iUn4J4R<5`*gx5`WsSFdWmWt=t!Y8w2_Z zj{e_APwU8}OuWQ$DVfzI$d5pH&dRFfTZ(IX9;()$QRgV`>z-BDa`mPCNip6@RcPHccJwv% zrn4+c7nq_rqSncm%`BM!p^Grt%K3$hJ${wJ(tcGZqLp?MAoDI$FI&|4_~NIDa)k0^ zJS&LB0wrNzg`0%jTm{81AJj?__mK?{tOm6j0rwWL5DN1J@Oxd& z)0|NzvHGjLt1X;1jD!hxpH0DezW7PFkZ0x#vQxqJxpCYmw)5a0eHW(gI;l%8mcceRVut79-La&Dj8tIJ){0OvH&+rC2=Ag zV_}4mr$8>?FOfwh2h8`R;xfd*XvSV7owGZ4vU{|iOd%aQm( zVYKgMpX*k;U+I~~fdc=2XMxe?FgKZWonRTCFvH&4W_xEVY;3z~K4dYd7;-i@vp;<5 zj-6Q-8?S@L)Gy8A!AEb(jUbIrXsW3wd(4|H`PYuDYsX1nq)i4RTVk+p1$8+uOTE`e z%6`1VrYRB4;~5%~-q;#)V_QIaT-*frY>M_Q6^A^4=cuzU<&!~k*GDtG4Xrps4y*Un z9!LrYmTqFoKjYMM(?89djcQxu?%HWJs6@waR2fLhDhR$i{q)`4USDP}^=4d#!c{S)P(TqIRRNY7!a_7}w!{hB0$ntqp8MzQJD`OsJdQ}enOo0c z#3Qkc;_d-)NBy zc!hb?Hj{P*sX&&jYiyu%o6B*r@q}+R(XN2t9X0%6_K3cC;{WPYc;{ z^;WH%{d?})O@i3S9s#G=-LoOQ^))w`O;d&sL0I1#6HaS!w{cP&GA zN$r+{8$QdOoGca{6flXE?45hjbiYGWP!dK#rTGYqua8divCj`n;zghxX}VRfy1jqY zlzG8SR$Eluv?@u_nZe9ZdX&%pM96t$yWUZ~c;`ElN`BIsm9-MQ78Wc9eQ0;z<(bUR zcmSPN3otP;bKc1zY|;!wQ4xyfx;CpCAlY6rdjU9_+J4ktL)`u-XQXQan566FaO5&sHrU$sz2 zJg1Vy?Ro*m5O`#O)w-hxu`G#NMqZ(qJZM})F>%ZRaYNS^a^mf_t91Ocas6XuS{z#e zd%|~b%BGj1*a11)*6D>Dg|@gDl=8tGa3jlFz7;k6 zzb4g4Q}1FiNSuw0NJ^XTYYz!Jv+rdpRnrC9@3k7&pwrPq9+6F za0mdGf}1RbfE1(cCwZB7haK$6HA%9vlENGWN;^a!RDy|>r-fn3ElseP zBa1@s{am2Kyf*{}K%z(dppz7h?$blMn7#z5L)GtAW0#5E=IHk7QPG`cV2_aT*o6P! zocQW_(Ln|{Pr}BJ{(ZNNT_%=jL?a#&k9{Q@KZYHl0L?@Wjh3%((x(Tl!svitqJZS+ zi?B1HymOCTCdj(83sR44H+e=0V4(_mvPRgMRE~=L!O0wtW@v}6*;n7c;dTXbrGq}4 zY%3MB{Ou+Z~uzeo+W7i z+(BQUBdN-55nR(^1LLp@-#E!juM<5l067Qcq7<&LrQUj3k>6c+mkdhwrwPyWAzz4{YF@wF%)0qho6c1EVW*Z7B3d}g8hBAA9@s-eRj*LP6 z7X&jh;yV=*e#Z&TyDyD)urxeG+}>v^IU@xLm-?zKzoJBdMHm~RbtqL&fHo{m*y1++ zL!rYBj=;HhW6`QlBKMd2&ypfY1p6=#VA$4vYwym=gP%21IAAtxa&YCpBZGyo%#Ji1BSQQf(Ic$()%*ACYSk`n((P;jK?)(9pNE;yS% zlFtjEo`Oa%ojZ+PfJIgN;dL;Xp0ElyMY+n$czSo++uDX(uC_@Ao8Yt-Xe|))yU0?= z&;d4g$~UC3*aZ(g6&~G7JQTz^S9Aq##@ZT*zh|?p1k2p$coKC^ubkt|f1jO+=Vp44!)hQV8%r9$mJcqeZ{uVpAec8O`Ryq+ai&*H6HREDeI8? zu5=3qLOtl;x$@nu7P+;^|G1%Hz3IlifpGff9E%fjPK?L-VnJKlS`)>*mU*@w5_i#R-gcEcA%^`qe3zZ-OqVB_cNB5l zaJTNLW_NqUD5eh=leN3$YHT7YMU#EjqRVwso@N|-l_OLCBkkcgA^G(CfraXFwTYe z{lQq(KcRl3WrW4cbD&m9tgR`3In~buB*Ofc2>F!Y1>F^#b+L2V`3&*eq+e zK8O>T0cd#xo;s8|;<}Z0tS~^dPFcJ58-- z+H#p=gC*rEPMwtH?N~@;ZZ)Sl_~DhsuBov|!J-y%@i^3F_K~`3)af15D!&qgFGWzp z^c?p#P2`50D{)gR;c1S6JAEaBXmwY8E22}A3+v*2cDWgcW2ie#(?K4MA}R2qzK771 z8|Z^GNuLp|MF%HDffn6npRl{(#74QfBOIW(Bd@qH@=~AcuzP2UIsak~_yJil9NiV1y(d6x>_{SLb*vM}c$N{D-F6nHymrOgeD9rT^dZEckFZ5-(ZZLN#|Z_8Iq9f_G= z6R+BWg0^m2^dNR-VtOVZ6EO(L`pT(+OibDg5>EP7=7s_`rdGzpKmdb)qoJ{l6EO#n z1;FrT@$H755d;D-2JO?*nNsMFlh_*--#yuEAf4ZJ8Y>pZ_A)t_X<{p47R zPY_q-P&KILW|&j_8FwrkDydgJ27`k-#hT&A^$tLy*L}2fxY*~zngJMjzD4g7`fNz9;cwHU>V@l4zcV{~}4Eu>m7+Y<*=Jlk#; z&gRdpXZy>g&eINk%J9-VF9?C3S#tly$2k5o3jcN|1|??$r#IhHc5pWSLn^56X#6&m z|F>6}J2*NCndv*cIg7OZKhuni00uR4BPTOQEhbhLVm3xbVm3B5Vs<7bVpb6Fk9$^D zR^qqw?b(~`kNejv3k&O?Pr%##o6f)FjIZUqrI}vK(*B39{U;KL-vUJuz@TiaVq^Zc zP>cA@;r`-*uO|M!$_oT~Q~EDn`0phg96*l0uHfLXRL0v)TxTPLBZ0)_M~?Z7W6s8~bpzIlpAi*#nHXoVvQ>JSTO#wjOd7?qb-Ky4^-})zhLPn;R{VFF zDI)6(54J%L&$Rq=m)cz?wn7)z_>7)V{ZlqnpZxtTtJ{pHYBFZW)2EZRb#I?_Hc}o> z;;1?^q)Bo7^eBqefU80?apVg$rkSSehZ1cc6Ana@?I0;@Fhu~E^v-!m{r70Bmv0}WTNWNu7P?~NH zdc*hg&oyHnEd!Vlh#btpl;3CMVo0h)ajL}^jf%Y>Gi-y5_~Eui^M}`LzwZ?(P;-V( z3_lP=JN0JG~4 z>v_|X+?&p0usg!wN9Lf~neYkFON7houl8xq)*g(;BVYn*1!-Ki>P%Txfb!rGq99x^ z2wEnGZ0}=C62o?%oKKL0+B3Y9wE!QOAWSn9K?}_}Nz!f(i`h2Kap5=CzT!taP=)Y1 zKT)oWF^LZ*$s`{(;oj+TdwFA#r={9%Qj|P!!`AlF8dHnSdZntpz+GF(ushA8aaco5 zTZMYTJw1_r5{t3f|2MZx1*cen^2CO9W;U`gdkG^cHO;;JfP@_{AaKt)@JkOEwH;Y> zkBAZLiKy&*_I|!zY7_R}Zy6~+S#uD_ILF2vrxsnZw0eY=yWSC5?!s`GO9VF#Rply* zUVv3=3iw|pOE);8M%npL+u1p+5t+ky!@H-kw$oSG&wYiGA^hzAPGZ)}0Zh%di;-XD zQ45nQe~fZkvTh@~FMrKi-?ydLg1~9cSsco%g*$M`C^4>7W++z0L8-^-buo^-tI2bC zIKmQvy_umGT{A7+q(V$)(bMInt5gtDNw96Qg^f=UBzLrwvsa6*14?=3a^={xyR{@8 zHB|8K&brtJQisz|QAuVg1-OyNFQ36+Pk(!T-UYvmz2Dm$TCvG8yt{`gcj4U+fz4Y3 ziqlv8-s25NzuU~|5vH)0np^C=ku7ms9;*_D1G8ZSpx;?;mmkv2b^TDuTH|AlAVxt! z`cg70iQi$XAlw2LyVDTF#2(_JB}+PajGa&ni^EaNX@E^k=J<_Ft(T13sJ51Yn}Iqo z3i~t!dmSrr$3=+en51L_r(^>nJTaSr=2zNk03!p8s&h{vyMzXuK3K^iRF2}80d6uf zC?X?5Da@3dnyN3BI|7K4Tf0xON9#WZQRO>14)bHk;vb%?J~TiOi`H^nFwC?FkmCBG z%hV6=$FF!PPF=QtyZ>NvU-ZybBd#hv)hI#5n3Nc|^6bLMw3{7WXDUtHd}sZ0dZ5L@ zN1xu*y)S$&_lHZDl~q7<>D73M;T9@hbx+Q8UsF{tO=v*Oh5#=<(T5=D_oW=j(;C}2 zf!^KvGfG`m2gHjlX|ZLrgEH+32S+PC#(e zQ4jG~3IW7&q)G5HNd7$jNNLh)Iue%gpnG<{0Xc`b1w4xO*s}qJF=(MEcUHA0HobW$ z_^!Y*U~5>6o+Mbv_QQsx08U3(FfYqWHRs6axBIbn_uPze8eu*6kU(*`@IwH-!)?6J z4upc4!Jb)D_AZui?A65w^JVvTGS>0iAhv;(D*qLerqmIYKu&wpj&Ti`@KjsB{#z?8 zlye?$p`X(T_+L-N1Pc`dCBH!agcW4Ah7qQ})RGN{9UaUA zq!Mo#hGP#hU(+DwRg2IF8LFD2PoU$ZQB4m(Y0#twVs}3r?;3pIYebSA6N8qBBqI}s ze69+-mq8)$nFcRZ)|BY(_f{l4CA(4;v>lyL3Cw~>^ov~3aJ}T-+FfU`A4(^)pybMT zcqiM+F;M?G*0XyMA4>Crt~kNghFwDGT`p8wOk$uHqgW8%q8%z)bK`_2l{$R+F?yp_ ze>9yO4a`Tr*$QG)=m=tmAqsXwoQdK+rRW{r7^!VcWQF^-C5~gmB`M9IBtLm2Q8Y$S zp+~%#qMh9#3%QJA;Z`A2p%jJldxF97*@@m6DjLCZsVvn>*TI00TP#eLmXLLP-r-Mv z%V{2#LP{jIO8Y?Mn=_S9`ULwK0D_!pyg>=_`DwJBU8}y6wrQ zXvym{F(q(hYlo)Tw z%21K<{@8LZnAAiXWHPy8SxB~%fB#*BF&mW4^eyJ&m#c`ZDTpnm?FJP0FmjQ;n6(M* z-0A(6a0Dnba;)7j4o4d3`n2)1aU@Ufo*(2#F6_a{+})32w_Jc9Qm1Ji{d>TsGYStL z=vyl&Wu)(785I^)o3%UTT$H%D^W}{$u27@8Z5KnMY+H}Tz6_^GGYr1BE`0{Z6|Ksf zmx=O3Nq4`z9#ub1ya>KPs^mdmCAj7HePI!;ja^a zP9qOMfwzN8HPgwAZ_7TPGhl5t!S@@SZeO5caL5pLeW3mg*l!WFBDDmT6iB=X>ht^m>{T^6~-R@w+ z^z>flSw=g?I4%)$U0ETtTGG(kcf3Bv=9$u^s9kgkT%A(*4P8rUspSW>Q$3do9v>a1va?V7FsRFnpZg8+9c< zL4WcXY?U|^cOD9?w)a9MF$?KCP%&duwIcOSFq&wsL+5aO57Q5WirOt*gM z|4>yU9I}rk&!IeDx8PlTb)tBnx2El$FgCVC9n4YDRr=1fvN8Oo|0wP$Lfg1;zS&aC zQp^&qUd&Q%hFAA-cqzQT$xHSu14>Jo$Ayb#WZi^W^~wmaGo*2rz>Y*Oi0N0LAMKek z16va1V8vqe#8fsXo(K2PyPQ|GB^)p+u^ zq{b(i4tav7x!7arW%|6su!{!F1e}ZBWh`Xhv+VPwiqwXN)C$c_L$<4Ni3f7!FOW`^ zd(Fu|TrEM~jkxPVhEP*vG+0m=A`hgV?=#hul?#fS^A37xny-6H=Sz!eYDk%F5n_wf zwT@vkEB%A&B+J5-GfOzt3VxelV1BdHke|7-7&AAEED`Hh_Y|LE+7Gsh5BdQ{oy=uq zF6=^x30uaHquSDS2%`C+pXK(k-w;hC`%~>M7YtgooIAH?d#1-DQS$nP!(oPV%cZlpNjnCENUb5@_{OPlU(`^7Kn(`*+H@MhZa>;H&G#Mcu zeFda7yIHR!<~J2`8k*!Ww6mdpa357Sg&evr@2+`BP09_|z+1=zO#Up?Js+@2tTUyq zXs81ca2G&=-~{{(Z3hZ3W-(=;DHIJdWQi-J^j(P$iKy~VSE%2)XKDQ9lAMrb?~-(3 zZDCIVS3+HA;M*uJfX2^dg0CjjNlI@_#F0|=EIS{obBv%6Ok~@VQ@xA$;SD}uI>4t8 zdm85@`Y#Y6)dNzd;L3nB9|H5b-~?v96gvI)PGK|A&Mv`4yO{c+Bu}ieyD=WfQ_nzP zL>P9$DQF+x&udhzcI}NchY@>6^>f=+ZnTs`E3XNqJ3r_s^jAfse@$)rgy7jZ+-)*7 zZ-hnFqjOtjI=E%;`L!qH_H_L;B{P#;B4p(hMlb2=?)iy7fdnUZGWKvoLlG~J43c37 zFO4xsK_C^uDC9%ELR1?xZ*9ES)AQrJXfz`3>evu?HFq)#4pi;Q{Vq|PgHMLdty*t? zJLAsRM2@h_=_bzMKC_LrL0Zw8k{F-QhLFa7&OoeYUV58p+x=PmdHG#t_4qt01-&3R z!w7%zL8@_T^MV?Gj76QKu&U^4RH<6Jqy?rU_av9v@*@bka#~}lk||ySe`~>zgw;BM zwY#ssL#mHzTW^JKJwxEzDvz^+pya+c;Fx$b8>NHsaaDg}Mv_{(I3%w>WVg|lk&r-i zpG!h0KM7@b;=x%E&$QKS;%|fJX(#m7wffSyK|rrQnQL3!IDz|ZQPZ-3Wqaph$w5;B zhsrOvJ2E~}xzpdWR78}hv_g~w!u)E=;hwr;m?ani+9l71%*B?wI(CWbbtj3nP8Map zp}jxPkYZVXj+1LRi=#_nu~x=3;k@D!$J9+~4Y0#1n7&3s=Ttx3$w-zTsXwm&_%i`2 zV*J8@r_tPbsbFP^e{fJ0*qk2?R;D(_ua)kuV$xx7p!_Lk$Z7Q4>51*=t;)dxE}Moe zE|v9>Wl6MCGoH&TE&~4L{rBGoERh8yzV4R|!G)^?_1|5Fe;hk6bqSJ-y6z200XVhT zlQU_jID|YK8swmZa$DEOeiPd2&aFAVE36c{>)@8tJ=3#c3g4^ITl&AWEH7IRJvxJ6un*|WgT=`a~Ui& zvSv5;M5tn74O$MKPihcaB~wC41R0wSjU`eK4Yg=wh7Qsmvf=>{9*$8^-A_YY&fFMV z{QBcHU_`ga#tFgo>)eIH$QK<#jV!x99c!((TXKyJ_+cm%|{vU zR%pAW5gO2N2nE^7?IxZMYHywpRckML9ixP9d;7p{Dg~v99R6VRk`KS`?Nwo+wD8ez ztPVB_z;%pP=PoiVJz5sW(Y;Uo)cxyAe=GPfu0*okF}9dwEl?@#o0h5}8jo^~`{B(& zOBPqF&F~~;h%5I2{48VHs)B00aog$)<67IjnYN?7Ms?xw4N)QA?N;|_u>bbUT|)y< zZXf^Iq0HCE6(T zhDJa%A&q`TK3`W%oFS`I`0>M3r%9EglJQ&IVk%%FxQre>!)wJ1c1=+g9czO=QhxX> z>f4QQ#Zs^zQ(O>rKK~${v=Bj2Z58-hKjBc9WXg7nhB_2wvXTZn%xZ*BY|yND^pgfV z7RJU8x(par=}%9m{_wse@Vj}CIs;u$8*DJOh9V#JOp9ab5Ke=gL@*0u($*4!%s))| z(UtMnUukQohYp!h!+(=!d2+xU6F8kbHP&Y-RsGEhznjarmxz!NGDm$_Q-yh~*jHo6 z`%r%&jrozkv9x_MNt`e>Gc85han_I}qo}<-beS;P{;OGY)L{yaqka1A@s?3AIvbu` zuPJh$;m3+^-Mj1UO&xhf>FJX83Lkm!B72MSYCW5J?jkR=m0GrHC$E$Zf)B&TWg{O^ z9}Uu#49`>5y^8kA>We^K8iqdgsOdK9=LDGyxIDF=`%F-#^hc2Tk78&W;F zNqlIT_Ws=u_C}U8*?y(a)IlfC#Z4C?PNxBkQO0PnN=rJ>@w1ZQKG~ofT~=CJ3fQf7 z{QkbTw%&v^0D+Hq9Cq##Q4hZXG-^FVw^Dz>rhQbgoZs`g8-ldd7{yIb|5QcKQQ+gm z%o??;==#h^;A0wYE;-k@E@kABJov*oY?_FY8MurfpTk)cbFjt6zQFaFIk*{DSROXF z5ETI5`JHnP&V~b69nNt8vTJ5=LPYORoRD1sjU+o4zXarafn}2!WIN;o=!1k2qQrTB z4Y$6}zPMSnW(*UkX20de)}bz1w%rE?(9gy@&9bFa!8M5FZ~Tr-Qj8IbnQERjHtdHm zpUllqN`LE)H3=0KR9uvS(Mq6eql}MFImm=uj*r~Ti_pZ!!)Zuq&Sn10h;v4MCzd@j zODh#8Ua-ArVpQ=wo>C2Cf)C@4I&Ya_SaZU>finvCnX(qN9)L8^UidkFp!^}pKlKGD zl+SAVl@l#H46FJihkI8wH7m(7GD2oZ9ksr5?3ZZBuV{ETn;Gt;*~7T6<{Q7WhYG$r z#yQ|`IrLF}W{dYuE_1}KSxk(ah*&}XAP7@&2|`QfQw;^XPu(x}X4@l4C6^;@vGAs` zeEH5TM`0oHos#&(o@41_DksS!I}}F-_@2k3cppVgot##!#c<^FYlCG>~mmrMqE7w|ktcl{^2}^tfWqJKO9_(-qpCu2~ ziWydM4CPj$I~KZY_QnP>XU@6K&lxtxA%^fbkmUCV0O`2e`td+t@OGvj7!5O8j4@jU zFv?c|sUz;{qYLPTpH)j98`KwdQ}r~1^?k$30pfP*FmKG2?@?viD7z|)9m><@ z?nJ1EVx6A{J@ba-If6`$J&O{iTa>zP#RZ9)!k2?T%<`b(VlUz7blyGx;EE;?YQK;j zoW@Eb-44i9M0gkb&hZ^^8(#Dmo^-(!(tQ_o2-z|JnRCSJs>Vd#cj}ypqDW#iaT zG0f2T#nfT|;yt?D4?#-i;Q8`^K7}x^X?`yL{7|z&*qLcxh_VDKr~kqN{&@NQ2Ao*f zLG1tLG@w82h5k1p_|JRx{}3mk|3RFL9n4MsFXY7dFXY7j#+`s{{~K~*=Xixoe?m^I ze??9}w*QWt{&>It*EjzE+Q<2yecg=gO#kI||DX40YRCQ)Iz0mzrbUbhNz6Y4Cd83e z?+Fz=y{m$;C|O7X!9TYXa#!AwZljv#BhPi)zyx<+5{1kW^Q{vf!8iqbLzi zQy^(-QTe&!XbXF}W}}5aQjY7afqJv!8D5LGsvStU5mkjn+bPL1xhl4L->emR?~jv^ z2UkKvqj%+)<#D+({`#-zI$%A?X4!K%d&8TFzgE7;9-{(^u5ee+lLd@AK0nuZS{X9o zZeHrr3`g{NQHw#Qjaed0XqyAxYbfTjvmgB)g~Kdt0O|td5a1Q&CESjjK|Zj1_Y~n3 zdg=HpWI*49fF*ihe!yM*xq@dqS& zgGF!8|0gW^!^!_bi$H&D`2RDo1pR5luPBK4jhwxbB1U4+TbuvtX8$6$uWt5+&4~ZV z`dYlagRP;Gv6B|V>lX(Yl#Sh-wEtq@Z+$1PZ)(gSukY{%TK}-YplIx9>+E1?>_`my z$6jL@V}wok2+HHHciy4UHAW z1Q{fVonGl4FE4}8YXx5|I1<0bx#FJy?cay;tvZf?|4|13!@n!>TEM?+@z%*w=0=WM z#D5^Qw_71w=eNH2lL^q@X||C5D|5CreQoutt$#Ecz#wO5Y$IU!#;~>iQ5J)`h9&g1htH__yg0E?I zAdnHr`&!}G?>f9f^?znzVSAmT7+)WAyk41Kudgo0#`voCI;uv_hQ|NWV;1^{4(qG# zANsF)%x@;&%)Onj`B|A>&sX`Y$}4Jry}nj~iRE7=Ut22t`hf{5VNOOMh#ABPWPCkY zSeR*nAW9&RlKM|Q=;mN-0ss<&H~_CD{qrDZWnp1rAvPiYhYZBZ!uUEcZwIl>KV`3J z(5nOgRR#jG{9Oim4X@Wg_`4q4-}Qj(?60x)H$8Ut*Vy};j04E_IwXHBkAs=@f688a z?r(Y^7FNbrpZrVSR~hr)?Sfd?U*rC7dar}=_jZ6-nHm3!>=jb~Jue&UYi#`0E-U+= z`^w2d|8qk$>MdU;Q{}1J-E#d$G literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/fig/sen_comp.pdf b/fig/sen_comp.pdf index 7b1cf7042e53e287fa63bedb398dad03a6edfb8e..5d3e407bdc71dbd7742ec6b28dbe3ee26ea32509 100644 GIT binary patch delta 1540 zcmaivc~BDv6vh*7f*1=ZSA&ZX35aDk$!>NrZU8-)Vj=a+5Net6jQ;Fsv#+w3|xm z7`xO$L%(mJxusb8`on}H6=swy>X2*v{p#^q%Q@dI%;^hU~Z-<;Y zkz!)hyb*e@*X~qOS%9swxu9?+Tw2ZAS<6$7VlIP@8(t>6mOZ{gjP-?mPp=StZBiE| z`9jk<3^4|9$k9}=(!Xq8(cO5?V$vW}L&NqfWWmDLVhV>VSE z9<0p{q?l9~s*Sfg(=dLg7R!z ziPXO1H@f+~nazJZbaKp6#q2XDSjkjc%2|S{*woz~vQ(!>%3OK~j~4xMe)WN3pqH+! zG0&Gtb1$wbjsj!X{Mhj#QXNh9x!=BbEN<2HP;G~uTCT6i+2%DoI6ZuzO&RVShAa7_ zRb8*V$t5=1nW|XVp3d9t)FiKFTQumL?OLby2b7u_g(`%rku?ueYUZp}z2v9&xj(et$3hVrF9l&$nk>Dtv$At^qg2|4IkG+&JTT@}Dbj0^q zo8UCIIeyfdhKI9{;QlsF8cVN2B3^0hfe&!5<34u58czeECBB?(YQRJ>6nAIS@hjFU z{2807Nwi@R@hT38|7n|wmvR|q7ytr69^P~SV&ZqW`;3?%1E4c-IWOnKsF~nNiN*{F zWI_xC=LtNC2%ar)QP2VKp8^sA(!T?Q!0^1;CmINWjD;MCAqcpT!w?kuOheIyyYqG+ z^FL1UF&Ko=g@zCeBOkzz91Nq#f)EI1VV~_H5dCwF0e$+M2M9t416g=Agdi}wFa%-2 zFn&wurNH=N7Q`2eQE!kAiBVKA-$W1t6$@DiC=@d}B=-LzKp4qGloTb5l}9C{rtbti z1bmDR!(xcZ7YSgP#qvhy<3J2TMTkJm6u~48hm@KYxhpMe$u4;e2|_RwBvGm2b>5`E E0mRNpm;e9( delta 1540 zcmaixdo+}J7{`rE7}5pRQKRWFUQU#UgjHYjdPJsj&8P_MG@*pTC~-Ip6bqp65JgrIcJLCCf{a z;~Ucn=^q(?Z)~^3!+KNLig3-Sn?jeEZuK$$vC92~TtA96{lSdU`7N!;GiV84ekR_u z?qfM&6RrDdtAjTovBRalW?{+F@%+KHu@?D^ON_kN5gko=s#}jhLa?HyynUy8DU>)2 ztWpQ-a(dLWnMZHs(N!-*A3ZRi8cF(4NmYMwB}Es*Hv`>4BGRJzu6z z2;38G3ch)MEjkVCsI(VWpEOG{JYYCvuI&xWXLNK?mG6k^fg+74yCkM{a>eDLb<6Fe zpWl7fRWxwvrJnP_)ep=I@2-O zeA@)eYHX>WYMxpWcZaP=k?rHn_C<7_PNucV)C-l}ZTV}UQx@9`y>6yGN~d`rW<4>y z67jxVw?aSA97K*U_SC+9j=BEY7X^E1p*7iZt3R%tBd0T8%Umx<7s##@Xi#>WEOuO# zaC@*PhbAk!5j(OhSBJ@L6zrDN$s@lfi}80M@o}Xm9twYRi8x^lI9~Th<@Q;}iVdon z8y^kQceML-JzIUCH~i>#TJ4K(u&%Fd<+(@oE@tPG*8r$aDY5bHMtXT76;C!5L=Ub23>X~GZ6oc4fa?OIal3eCYdc?hkF?rI&L`QD; z7NT(EwH(raRdiYAac`MLi|32TZb-30Rj4a(T&D6@>uF#-)T@1<^eOQVITS= zrE0|LRxMRVeW$cOv9ZN3q*VUa(c#pnu~%e*Pip_g9X)->SMO3*ne|sgV8T#ckHKDzB4L*PWEZgD1e;Ra8OFE z_=aQ+Lr0T?b8)hX0Z2VZIVokDDQ`Jq6w<|#MOr$GNw(ECrM+hAIt=0 z@uO%1z=2^7PV!vsCo}YtI2*C4mC#@yR?0 zWy9zKhM>qlO!A)?LNRo{1RyYXA>%9%0|W*0C17qD?mRI-Vesj3EC`x|D6}AmBG>|k zAskZ0ca#u390NE9;jwuLmyHuVz=0ryhvE>7voSZ|M0NPz2tAa_62wIEqjp7##QXQs zSv-hC;1~}OKtKraxi`TGpU=kx0Ot{I2!T_boT%dXh`9K#md5Q8QUS`vxKsv%*yu+6 E6PX)e4gdfE diff --git a/fig/three_scenarios.pdf b/fig/three_scenarios.pdf index f24e443a2ef7f0e4c8be5408a945bca434939389..4e2a400873dd5b3d4306ac1e0be1d80faad69869 100644 GIT binary patch literal 13526 zcmajG1yr2B@;?kMR-{m9(PG7Yg~g?KahKwYyDr7uDemr4iWeyE6n865aV<`9c$e?> zd;jnGJ?A`|$z+n5Og@wB!h}XaRGbCK%8pLcmEYCe^}Q<#9Yg`3ur;ti=i_6OF}5*< znNfh@93?h!b1Rs!1Dm)N6lN@HY-np_EFggH2y-xoTBEz9|JIa_TI9fNy;a|Nt6!8$ zJ%|q=q~LARqNroXI9E8IDHH=}WjAabC1Lj`_OM~CaldB4=cTn)x)Y57$!d|m_q2Ra z)8yarSN$F=QbNI%-}bP4cPDp0y(2P)(<~*Sp!aANzAHKA9GtzJDv;d_AfS<1S??n- zJ~4704%G+th~3Y5c>OdJ^A^1C3u#?_L}kC+WStR!koONDu5AoZ$(@|kzQ9NI8_6En zx7`aSFiLm3zZ+Ea=a|nV`xPQlv@q#UIj}ExN#{JZiWDi={4?sxT|9=a`P}21#BVw5 zhc9{x3*dUyU#3uuo}M84XayH(0A0!YTiG`^ z{vys!&pj1ocpZ@3Uee0M4@|KQ&o>@e7MY0o5RBhI`7z6TU%jpQmE)foS@e@_Evl>| zyzmOJr60Cx=IW}m7&?>WH8RvT);N)SVgLh2_6FvM0NDrY2nB|;;{hYNRT!BEQatFJ zH~kmE9Kvi-aX)4kI9Pfg&*m~mJuDWV-*0_-L(eVao$wZM*-(@3r8!XC@~0^w&=(XP zBi$$bxtEF6U{K=YO3#sDg~dX<^$J`47AAC$c%5%a{hf+oC)#^4RzL7^tWm$%muq?w z=lZ7E68nfMmLtDuMMF1!ACWK1TMB{Fzl1qAai^@}v3@T8&`q%P(0~n3S_!X`vS1wZ zWt_3IiL}W0TLna5nK)~yh8q1|BbyWv#ADI_Hq8XOW*n^OtL9_}uc?nM@f2@l6j+53HQsH;{maeq0A zNIsg|a9V$h%aU;HE@uL!Vy9oHeL-nFJ0yTWNPZc z4aM-3q>WK*AU2V>>_JX;<*!d1C?}mP9m-{H`ew$IYp1fzm~>gKq)uNq=zE7I56J}T zS8p(ZEQjj(9>VJ1CU6S7OE5V(eapc9P51J5iYXd~HU6|%Uu2F|8ACsPEJMXDRG!I6 z%)Tj|7em#a@Kxd#SYtWqFO%<{Oh)HozJ<0T6=nt(IUJQyF39Mzm1k=Q9;m(ZEb=jvUCQ%Hcb9hW40)ls3=ITd(LSqtEA;e|4O zsFiOC3g6iGS8|)GFI&ImpXnhx@_u!uNq6J^O6?-E=?~*6N7^W+^t_TmQhz|uEd-fL zSkkHF(^9Xnr@t%ofr->aoUVnAgV_j)dU(n2RZf1RYW1OEPU~mwst3!>mvv^yY?n^R z=y5OJUBWQL17i1rBtCspSmDz>?z1XUxv9df5Fs;Z_=seKKPG8yNHPmOzj=AWa+YXP zLNTZWkRJw_RqM-r)uK5Rz~5VF$2im5eJ-uyK%#~TCPI|N{-&>Crm)0leOaZjvfpA% z7yq3hZxD;Xr+!ou@Gf4ZPHNthd5RNeIn#!9au%Ptrc^(3vdxgSCS#@^jZway$?RfN z`@L+#T+1PE<3jiSD=h!2KG}!@=XVA}8eT%LgEj-QN)<<=)lTXePV+F|QM#`Df7&(Y*{8dv`u^vu+uN76xnr(f|t?#=+t z{VXo<)f<8GrrZ?W*v9DZJ3E|uIt2H zhozv-m*UBLyWCnQ%W?Cl*XE^qe{&IqVq*FUlZrG|1QQp94yEv=oNa~(T1y}f2i9Tw zW+cYKB7&ZH2)%frIGuy=(H%bJ7AG3RX5PYOc=K)YAIbpsBdU$la4c-hh^SkPSEngL z;{Aj;-VgP@MQboySLMFSL&eqPn4&p`%)?Tdwgza+Ec&Km$$z zg0w_|yEbl&g!53@*}&Gohj5YP>?S+Vo{$K=-=Xjs7Yxj)8=98=TX{#vEK4-F@-(i% zfMBFkk|IZ9?e=w}&%-VrQPKFv^M^7+gx~aT#QgHR^<+l;er=&?$2fi2vBfPmH`Izo zOdfB8+&MkuaMH7N1M$ubYeLg$+C(MB)bY+H^O)*iW<~(I)bXAXE8gm%@ncnwWh>U8 z{`Oy@YgZDL# z{V12f`AV1_q_1!!S<$5!=}4ct2m( zgLOt!s$(EKaW%xXQpM4Ogc@b?u%DNXRizKf%!8yaZy65B5IWms10D!b^KZ0V4Yb?3 zdzJqkOAmOoRy@=V{^G9cJnTr^*-{*LiW#Oct6^*cq!FfQ|8Y&7+I zZPuNR&|*U;ZOltYgHo^U+2&b2)KfVNNbTV~G-4%K&Y}jv0x@i}zDRB@osk)lT0+}C zmO>Sml%wZ(tzDti+B!+Y)VZPYzI7Vd(j;dgTpQb$oXb%dFY2%k+uNaVo^ZB#=$K@l zpE#PvY6wQ*aQcyqxWhXda(0H@9loql-o%>d-pi&8-RuHpHOYm$7Ekp!{p>Yw22w}% zyUq*`KazDgEMlnJ6kt-*qi5dp=j!u+arSCm9-bb(9K}x8Oq(zv{n%&_s2Lc+@X z&bs5|wrh#{yXpqD$b|i@<8(ek2iW=3(eU|u-$#qOlA%M;C$_Vidx>GR z*NA%v8I9VoRaAKlGYpEVhFTr_bP=tCqG+7+PrV-mt-0$K4R-Tc90yr`HeEJBIY}0p zwhTdD7tvZsq~vcyhOH6Z=cVd8hkMSwE1MS2XsOi64ia6slc)D`>{)3?pVhvvNaOV> z7-Kyv4cK|a@n)Wd`Y`8(GCBJbGD^Tc--kYC7#36boZT8gZ9VpR8x4d>5jx)+M0Lkq z3+({Mu(jBA>8$mbcQV6LmLNYbss&C7Chxq#2y=oN$)z7ve3the zaH#mr<1Z|oB#&?Zhd|^Dn$u536HAs^)kLlp2s^IhpM~IG`4M(HpVVb`g0K!hIb%61 zi#*5L)D2qIo(KUdEsRgk9@=OxOsXa(e`xj%i#u7fHdxg8Q%?wJNDfoC*XbUCJ*UDz zDknp5mPPjHiEl=?!GF!FSX?}#Vy813nb-g&uF{r!TP}U9c!!_kU?Eq#YHW@k=9fNS zxitMdOwWtl*Mt=aI9E_C2ueyLB;!LILko%dppsNPwbj6SS=qF}-}58jJ8L7yS2D@L z7selWT%Fz31G}-vHkAMH?r6|X zg^=)C+zHs3K1kx?JavLiCyEAu}Y!#K}EPY{==)t zcPbM+?^STy?!$e?(x({X&~OD@h^aygH4CBaE~(w-2cQT9S^T0GxDmRQ(#3|^hQ}-K zI7KhF%MYurA8ahv`_PGfz29~nGLA(y?NQUB>&UE=m4})yLE?2~cc<+e{U#FhiDtv@ zTY0xWj^E#^w7q_-NE#7+D%aNJX!A36Hqr2k<9-?6)K&nRLJLx3OoP?c#Xex|U|NOov5do_| z&<5-U84c@B{sXl{fLw4kIDjXe8jl{_)pTI3GEw?H&qNwhh3um64 zC?ok9)0jS&e(NC67qjc2l;C-3!1uW-#Gaw2o_cPnt|K&~7^FhFr{hCXj;!qJYRmTW z4{LxQfm=l3slHx?a}HpqMIk!s#?9XLPU>X=SF!^14FfAWeb{Fy;lP)%1~609N?v7o zW|QDfgBd($6CWda*foprLXZBSQAV|c%b{<>>VWsHY=@n9zf$20nK$9bL(K`iksE z+sF1qHc>{Hi5BjG{QbnU$sZng#@TP#DQga-+$kasrVb}@{d;#QncYQw-&~~Atx&l{ zx*KFVk_Gn05e$`#><@n4_&w}Sc~skcw5cp=o|#2|_psvr?9;IPWK z8}>Ftc4kJ7V^dMf_a;b#l2biTpu;o#mmy)1emHS-dV*d&*r7q3$!wt}U(a2eWD=xl zK}&=z1}(zxt=X38^ib{7@^2v{o4H z2ddJd?#1_S?h>Jkl&F<~^QkMuDuV(QoOU{ebH)RN6en{6g)4o`8>4l(b%Mrqv?D|k zqkmYlYvC38=$S97^)6kfkV>q0RCgzROv_>WIIaIj#TG5by5yVpv454No~~-1BFth4 zC1S&LzJuJ#k6%tg7bf~az6x6V$0u=!sgn3%k~mv@>!Vkgsa5j^@{}Yr^O8zX+-qj^ zIwisS;j>rl5y74H1H+@e_mKBUg(wkMUPpGP-&a{D#UEcLG$&XR6JN(KSbQ)5FW@X? zk3G8&76hE^1}-nB47W_`<17!iwWO>XRm-Tx@N|tuJHq}=0JIVzeHb zT*R(b$;ik=|LXOD`Pjs!`H9#@n@F zhII?;c6Ig4^mz$YL_^kozE0nS5~15ugdH&lwd0sin~B0-9-kKwUDkTTOnCg%Ed< zPqcoMe$$wi2H|D4P(>0-khwy_s~Xh9;RU*4G<6^o(1k;zVZx=WM7I)R`<8{3L2K8- z+@jL+Vcz+u{y91IW9qn4R@>FVQt8qU-CKMe#_PBZyBB*JRcPpk%V#EOnfrnz<}Pk4q@eC*up8CVr0?{>;h;!>0&M z8#DUO2geLU200Sdz}FFxM%CKix9d8+z1E(9n`nEw_Ow)XIS~rc)EfHZ(v8;fsCN?@ zcv_zoeXxq3l})Fi$t(IpiNEzwq@7ht#6{lCOcqcA_O~2lFdwLkbr&z!$w(UXbcQ^3 z)qSRw8{(N^5B%N4vF1pHI=_TZw;}ary#T|G z^JDzBHt8zRW=F%gh(FJhg&i2i0)q2p&~xuwlep`sy*) zu{dfXxBlT~b>!{aZBkoaBkPv{LWx!pJAiehm&B0$+)1m*A?z1JuYLOnw~-Jk2fOw( zvpL#CC2?-dUCDPEFNcwN4QZ1W!I80-IDp?9VFlt1? zc29XgCrz2eN4yhQ6g_$}|J< z20_Cq*`J4QL8GRv84Q+#-PD50ebm+|_bF9FgDFR*0~skUjAvZ>+aTi(8SQwrB=HFa zspnFrlcNQCGD!udHC$K>r5r6kOvbf_vT@avUL-3)wHXl3mrE1tg?!b7brr%1UcQ3h zORpikF>V0c3dj`M>==))P%@Z|x0&N*>boVXI{s#wFh}=uC@*WYuLOYDX29z0YKz@8 zToagFkQb)rQtZ^yI=QqY@p)43)HUPt?&MwGi9tgB#YtiZlg>(9d*m99l^+KlQ|OM4uRdlD7?7=>pta!z1rc7% zdk4Gr8_N41!m-JCUTjB_|4{-HkCbLID;X1~lIxV{~BjK9%0JoRqV zDjBrgVM0kO_4Byk=c;BJUwQGPi|P30jmG!R=FV!r@p`LrK7zddO5+VGl>{DR+9De$>hBlWGv<*Zj=^9JVCS9+yCk zXUOk-)4jMm>bmhfkcW?aeVezBJk2P)r6rt{WD`5ol{V+cQq(3|-?g;?HJW$JgKk71 z5N#znAxTY*A$mP6?M7oKvJtIn#|(K>cHvyFEJ`ZXm3lu67p}Mt^5uDL&YAYKnn#Y5 zc#Da0%!X%VsFs)$|TC^J?>YJnC)@DwH1(;&wmf zQIJq~pg0yHjB|h|V-^gmb2@8@{Z+?vzjJA>6;NZLMAI-UuuS-&#WQ}if5g$)$3W6w!eHP)AE+k z5!vl&E=_%Zd(+BKD$rqB+&5aWp8V4~L8PRDKT{J=Zfzp&j97vR#iV37fP1X9!+h>! zR4PNfD!CKKvC>@3l!RJPCCclnQW|20lKN&Q^=FNFq*Q zX>sSgQM`t7J-gk&ZSHMjIy{&fFE%fcNGhIzSQDbJ8z!e}{xrr^VPTTxMCUS2`fy#5 zX*NznF}v&r&Y&&Hv2>`C(+O&^tMOa)#I)2@=`7b`{y|pqU|ZVfB>6F4jH>(^-c{#; zYKWb3kyi(oahvHL-wW)Xu4?Nw*w#jkUs(x!16%6hD<+q1F@y6G3;G?5WmtPS!fOfZ zIC0!lgiJ+1eln$@$;7Gro1y^fU~JBHJMdQOS(>C4xA>+NxB5u*x2@CDEzmpoe^S~L zP&ycJDBtpswIh;%c8mt%XCOIu=-R8GQv323q=qP4ZGH51NAIK zgMbc)m}wIP5niL96DoY8NWXf!sGJ)l#0bAgU6!vzh zW1#_fySnA9KpDBI?S5xSIS={Io$ANJXIXL0n#v7V!;9GsU$m?;KCbIF*A$wl=4t2z za&kP>SdTXH1u6}THp?4Zmub42N@OZ68-0);AN^g?=q_rfUULmXf390H@#gEG&Yd`5 zrHYo5=9eVmsu4ADgq%z}>Z~P3`mORW>4*>s)PQzGe8KFlq34XvSsfrFanT53BiibI zLxUPxCwzy&}1CABuY&3dBkaUfCoC{mt9U2#gdhgwc47& zr&BJ_)fqN1?+5J9M?3YPwhC&IyngzV>p?D3FVoB2CiNH2S#vG>(@g<_j|=TxTBm1q ze0-Ig)gpm`B3TKoTOv-Ce;#S|g45}dBu*!VlQfeGsn8=-MZVIO-Nv3EqR@fWkaR<{ z``_gosER`R?ZvLeknEWyxLC7zJ4v?<(ib(6U`*9Kwx=Ov`*B2G-@kKckkvBzD_W=4 z=-;@>gyCY?5AJ6iBB$k&Jj(I6Yhc~}uTOU;zqP`ezJgY+ zFL;mY8Gj~WTCtGbF2r;guG9PspPTMzm#Wh}(j`JuGbPF3F{S5a64WV?9UUEb$?Y_B zL`&|N7KjxyU%lOW;wEd<#Rz`nR4%);Vy2&kjn=m0;xyvnh(iZ-8@Tm3vaE<{8UOm*;$2+YrcwGYRzC?G zoA)GRtmg=^z=OeWQS5U#MubByR%}IP-yj94io@FwhvBfKGl2o`h7SLP%-8b%rvBR! znR@Q8Euvi7uDDO6-%Zj)hUN=(+q|Mu>lW>PWL+ZA=ma!&q@}&kQbmR2M-KFAzLF+|xGgP%xpo-lwm|KIWQSVee!y%M*XTCmP-q(1@0!j2J&a{q_9T z&9-U7=56PTV2x*0?_C!f?kug14(ZP(wktOIt`FjRvplv!+3qzgFYUE$zG`Nq4%!Pe zsr|WF9~HRXP#)zwIghfj1r18z3!bg*o9c02L`+tc6Bl2)>`ACihX+-E>&*K((tLh1 zr!JU7`Ec0wik#Xr|Lq9(EhvWS91_06Np+BheBG}=1i=LhTuoQ>xTbX!dCD#$HB3|H znCTI<3X(JVGjyQ($q?}N9GawfBAIT-=UdF#g_cpQaUHaCa|CxKc70LY_yCeCJcQsa zS~@sfqsykpS>-MY@`zSf+t2l7gG@ zk~m4(GQH0+d2=sfhEYgcTQl%84a?-g{D&3Z58OCL;zK_z{$wt5JA4MSCPlCd6*yluoIzwtQ^NBxU-1jdR`P-BS2CTya8*En8Twmo;!#UVLVH z!oU0R#`F&J<-~KU{3G^5aBPO;ZEPReCL+yT*IWIN)tz_`Ik^p$OHElN4c5A3NR;9O z^6ntEt?j$ec)d~RnmL#FA$r^JR)w9Z+JvcbkE|W7bsj{Nr}U)glt&})MFhq(OCzkF zj}4v7NlYpqhJP{4uCce0mk>OLOzRnu-CwO@nb}!u zk$NF00be^-B}xR&^2INbp7xt?HVA8_g zjx>=_M;TR@>p{q_SZVB9q{|lTTtloI-j+xI_cqcL9@pTp>#>xaM7jVh-EwZW%I}Qo zuZSyV?abg`;M|>3hPAfPrcO+3Sp)?BOihJdjOG+nH2b~LGnbaty;~+J-hI=g*D{%^ z25^B@?PBQdq?cFk*PNny-+gdgJe=uj%|akG$%P6j5S@6jkSYE``GJDWps26xU{YwU z#GKqNqapP)mZs?|Ni{hZ;NxN^gt|3DEt2j=He2 zmdCDmq}t!H55}`@b@%G&JRXmzOjksLVwaJs7*X6F_A`{qD zfNLn&L3HBW`HFmd@RIa|^zw&?L)_>F(;AfoPGok=4!~uCZ}#Z!%ByHoVsl{O&#fEg z$DJ0}rnq%e>@?<+MOJCI3tVp!u@i*V0tH3QAtjo4Rq-sc6i-&AZ>!Z6QMPXRQ2(F& zzp%?oMpQSV;%&M3G$X5(90r$UExWN;pj*4+bl(%cd%D`6Y><5RzB8D$=s>p3F9MB5{g*jzA-voZXH0#_HJ=z!^q-GOAs+cG zyl^hYqy)$Le*N|Fx#!(6vu_jfAy2)t0-?!O)L7lCUnccgC?ENcWh5^2ON=LG1z@j! z{<^<1%@0YZF->`-#4{3%w~f_POr&QkIaIz^yDu-4_*@e>AKVfAP}cfEFxR`s2UEU^ z@ekCTMlPBr>aiR5r69Y*MvrO2spI=SB;Cdl;+>cZ$ zp&H;nUL}Jy%l(ZT(XbmBi6j#pRxH(yiJN?b#4O@E)QZF`u`9!j$fQrcBGoQ+j(8^Y zOfBc_oGor8als&5m6)-E-m{q;+0z`P^Z+kf!6cuH9o8QN7F5daCOs0pCJpHw+T{Sj zws)26%={Kid0lD*f}`!$bZ5=>{>;M-4GzV6mL6BBdN z0S)Ei;sf&{48_a=ldoq;!RzBWCqg`$>~@|)wJ|Bh9}IM>yLf{ewtVO2R?UnYtUi6R z5Cha({w!~Q@8^o+^4vcr^p~Dx+7cMT$NrX-JR@Kewa0|+J7-4#Z64r+bRq>io}ZF2+CTnfMF9d6FG5v!~5)>z^T%2`{Wh zHAxDqbOx<*V~%Dh=?%;wwOB->O{nF(^wCnpQ0S$3K`h}b$MnYqpFLAMVM88g?!8iLY4g2?xm)t+4Yj&J6 zpC!{w8z7utODfs)9Y50L-T!2Nvl6E$IZ#T?JHpM{e~1+MDYQg(PZ9!Qir`?dck<{A zDFdvbofo;aba2!6XCm{laz8uP5Z=}re`#K(_$&WD@h5&@%%el_7wZupCvlref{Z0O z^C6Q^0j4=(Ym&H1hMH&ZlyQE?K0Ir8EZOJ?SoA@XMc95cZ~Mr_tsF}hTtG^WynJq<9zqo>(lHrJ17{g0&86WW*e;w;t);3z**vlzTnrUAej@2}lgl<13Q< zYU^J1SX=xvxf;t=4n~Zs_uKvAxP-0w=1hGvCaUtRtAsqZFW6m>x-*#T6vWZI;SnmT z+c`p@rKjx{bG>&4k?RU=q3gq-JDz%>?fI-a${}h?a6pDXOwgNsiRe!IV!O}ukldm5 z7{{w}dRO%Faz#FJF)GS~cm;#L$$vq}b=c`~HvL0Fcy{FiSz|Q_1*VPFgIhf5OeB6ZDN{w#%XbI*riINA!7R%OvqP7;#lj92OBzj{adcgg%7WZjxS;n|f#ln_<%7+PfHWd$qVctoR~o=b32$VJcAitm4jLvvk415Jxns@2F4Chn7OTu zvay4?35&3;l@a<=p0lYV1v{L8iwg_ex@fTgxj+;wU;vl`2;h490C4KCNy4C3=7vHx zrdGxj0CYAXM?+&97zGzM5S{Hw5^!az;)iky&a-12jC0}^g5+_Bu z-M&>mF0|1^Q~ccKW?szxOWBsa--E#d z;v4z~KvC_f-jgGl;Ge<2j2ZRCw;hA!XUN8{6A|DgX->ii9{{|YFIr+8CBXH&6N zwK0FX7eMg@+yB5Z5b!Vehyy8}ob{jWz<+Cp`v)E)e~GXuIM^C08^g5N;P({RRE%9< zI{zLX|JLg-_bNb5joB2S4o^|X{xkralCh($lY^nLBL(nDScy&6*vK6E6wOZx!0>pFH4`QBDPLXzW6s4 zz<;})@s|z}D0~C5HHFXG6h6tnCXLP}Z)a>HWcakBY5i?1HjR&(6gEy)R)6~dz{i$> z+L+QC+pwrAGyI23|B>hmpM;PT%*@t-Ph3n~901^egM)+P@1@wk(ZX<=3jhEC1mFh4 zZ-cr-#Dk?>smSgv0hfc|Zs}kp7bg z1aW}iKL2ky?*ASS2xNx`=YPt(8Dg`Y+aPcT+CcQb~&icQJZ7LLQe@Q%(VX=7qb0sQMy5WFHvp+&(b z#tw#vfgnQM!s4RroT8!-b`F3r2M7!hVh3?^f#J~jzeSz^FKTNjVrFb;>F8ul!3Gv$ zXBXmTXBQR|2Z=yHV0LbHAP0xImF(*7p6;I7`VGCBlnfgOI|M+F*pA5qa09_W2NP?6 zkPt`-YHtCz1o9v$>L3{_TR0R31j*PM!=X}8QwKAshzP(54ucxo0o*c%bPa6gWbg}B z=03ne<7cnz!>RXhwC85_yx9^Y7GCSGOFCq$zc#AGaiKmu6>O<(A)kTSl@{KS^kN-~ z9F8`BE}O6a!^H2!hwRIXA@|cGmZ^@5Q3IE}m0I0q)xW(fM(`B zgKEHb9EqC~QS3N~N@gZeTS3r&r2;=k_n-QjTQIL^%ZN zS@jOAHPYr0;}9RUH;|aDUEv64ezr&8&IiLe_3V&)7DXx-Ov5}AyoI^XN|J^iIub22 zogJ>51L%0P7Beej-SMAPsz2oFnJM~NL|g}$V8>7o>|D^n7!UQ>iq&Xy4&>6Zxg@qo z-&AC>BrY`u)HOcGKsZGK1Ii}`be+a)T3@>dX&G7v%H)#spq+IptH13KjrRvieIH7X z=iVuJtrHZ}p5Tw{EqWhh^JTHGPl?v8q?IADkA+8@|8`V$S_oj`Ediy-r@gPZBuQ4^ zhxj=v0i+x~W?X+-q!5af)F-k08caNWMn-yno93+oy*Sguy!ajwwx1n>yw3_7cxl)U zSP}|k>Euc5(N1FvFsR-hJ&jLV)_*C^5_os`1vLrkGuI8 zjbj8yt|8~~T?UklZ3lmuRMy!#oG(wBAx00alNVCdVh7a!)PHh zIgMjDx|9XRvgEI@%*(R0^1g8zGdZ%*5#A?Md{e##rXYS-E}neX>g)rm*hbIZNl9x# zT;9GJgp7ZS?pB&$8Fg`c$iBfp^GB&u7vFEr* zNU+_38LgxSFbOgxJz%D=scME=HA3XNHP09^t(l{)dS{g;Y z2$l8@?gsoI=Y-wSL3@I^edAsXIk@up4#u~G8zz)x2+KDXHswy5eo3%gx0VNvc?xUz zlrSPrkzLK)7farU2J&PXQRt-`O^spHG{@mV*KUO-L1#(!TBpbgwR@(3FWM9lWSka5 zIWz7+#ZR~fM>P?b#9xw+7Z0wLe@Tgm!s>=R;vQZ&@g;p=wVzB%xE7cSC4XpsXl32y z$io!9y#3NRWz|VGDP|^DkMivMAyqnTysR}rCx{gBaoO2n|$bWbs$Z7`L8P!t%C$ApR zOCFdto*g5!c+;w%q`rA7LvE#}N3Iz?xiv9mGngVFZLuutNG2v|_cTbxvc9IwLCroG zXxqE?sng-9yFW)~c~-gV1TgT&+n<%X)RhNwlX@Hn=j}f)!LlnxLT7KOFXMuI+b7qn zIvriUU^Vz5XociRv2dS@4sm{cG06VX)0vOjhdMV|Mp3^|0;>!S?^OdnMx#Zs>huKe zrvE!F(=O@*tWdde=At>#ylA1Vr5pZGjK%mg3GDfgD(;!j%)i!uGA6YwU(F9w%(f%$ zo_Io9@`^C=#}Xm8FS1I=MzFXXNi;`nGaiEi^ea zFo1eaXg(D?{sjr%MM=DDf+`UemD1J6IB@$sA=OXCBDQ|Z4+;gs3QqdA>rYp`y~Aa- z?-h!2=I5BLqGom4#`gGu1{B@~hxx966%xPunT^&KwtdL%1|>aV+jX0pdJ|6&BX%-a&qz-06^*vaAXw% zf{|P>s68CWbz7p4WT=yaGt3m~ge+caFb7i&C|nPOEN?)NCe#g%l#_OY%WC`*<+xRd z6p?X2igR%M`asq*kRH%); zR|gmXks6$DRsK!%R{QUg`iG>XG2GbJ!QxL9zpYn>!i~+4JwT2>bp16p@4qYfYZ?HM zgfd9Q0cK}x3jnFADIodgVC3)^>tv1MGdyLiD?J?dz8^vCHXBl31IC{uBTq`(fU3sGkvDSG z_rmVz9g3m!h*4V#_E5R!P!S6rirov36B>Q^o8O+2Fm{68?p%J0KeaV$oy7x%X`cBOBYi1&-b5txcK;Q`H_LE;cNoG z%?g^xoqZcae{JB~Y5gs@{$tj^K2?nEp#RsEl0c>zWR_v$dJrpApN?#|`;g$j*7*hf^TpEM4*J{obS85hDb? zLVdLu6n{rG3=z5#8_P(&^f>M{o~{v6A=qfY{QF*3Lrw)2!m~4OSp}E%X+w5@U|N#)RllHJnqd{SnIyv z4cb14K)qkqb@!3{sGfG9epdD3tK7G~2r`N9YfSMRV%VTvEt-O&OJP$Yt_#BB? zP8M)S;EW-MP+-_AZ;h7k*%tWYD54*fah0%dMlwzf)Nmgcq@{&_G;a?OQoNU{GXC?; z#^RgIBiY~_?5jBQa{@E*r|u-2blJQHgHDX-nc|jV{jhGQmsjJm>o-ec27BvR{MNIzZz@p8}YZdI(Zk^&7s$e z8uwjuwMH>{Pf;6}*O`tfdzSBhI{{zgzK99&!~EV#O|2&yMbd;rExS06Idb1We!6U3 z`B`a*WyH*XGBF7;s6|S>5DOOOE!bUQq_5x&B6tg zD(7`>v2tnG99kB(YrjGfG8|pqPCMPWm!V%{G+yHVZ)ZSdlB3) znY4PMyfrC9PVwPq^DMW7vh%a=o6ktTLksDHa*f{a4Gat|3h&w`bIsYB;rt}7kf~5- zUg5kevqdzAbEPj-EXqFcQkKR?*98y7i#Qi(o~7@C{TdOUbtA2`g9;_SzHxZ;r-#(p!upY&ZWh?ucaf7GAo6JoQ8Z+Gp3 zTX$A9e{~1-*^mvl^KP?o)I!KAw=POOO3%?(jU&D)az&IrBCR2!0)^bUj}Ko^l7+vs zTYs>%!>$#x@Q$a_bxQGBiHgZXtpe|N)4B_l$4+O*Zvm<+SCHry!Q@JQxkU(?~`J=MF@{Swsb z%ViD>d%C~vK!8CZ*5>4dV_#`p>1+ROdwko47ty@7>fGGKL;#7LZO)yTDRh{3h~X6) zC9=3c?3b<>QOu?u1-m z&bD3N7JpgSY@BJlc6CYi95!2F_7^5(!&I-JB41lNq*TMIYpzDs2H0^T6fmy#2&*sz z;jyNWmn8N^lINlJ)uQKfTuHdtd>tU_gC|ApwSw%Q(Sg`>YjPQQ7`Z)SqDo_KZ4mE+ z98YF@m#NA@1`c@t=Hyl7E)&X;6`gAHa&R*Q0^ziE(Gw|MA>4eZgX4bck* zKVUBX+zTV=mZU?WMCBn2-{j1k6`Inbkl6PKLMbTP!Ni>bIyNjM! zxOSuPak$m3j5rZY-c(GFlBC_sM&aC%&bfGop zvc%)7yYI8g5USKic3bYV%72@NQle(Cz9OQdY%@w4M~ETtJEZMHhetAnO`WcUKYxrP zfuI>uB6h7uqgy~s7q)h-WBWxjQ)fzN6JstxqUk$fNH0*%8=OXI--cZwe0A5cSe0^c8a`h-Ze3y^?l zO$|(3mt5_pE0=Ju@m1)uPGGW#fBPVDz*}BBq@h3LwIkqX)1?>TWWFGYVP%BMPB!%; zs`SOfyGKoVY9*02kEoYu(78nHcUFx2^lF_L7zjQzZY)mkA7?G*qP+95tC(&tas^1vjeYHGUrd9c&{37uj zQ{A;j97Ra6DX|9Gy+n-g%6K{AYrV89Oo>i88H6cU_a{Hf?3HFTD%46lBXc)cFhvUG zl7JR@Lv&;$959Q&eYO`~5e1e}zjk8O&z(K9FPmxWD z^TI;1iSFXOs$RzVt!j!twkLU%WRdXQ>)u=;Na*3BL7>Dw6M6|1PWKCcNdgE8v54Pf z*RTmb28wQgOIJwCD@i40oNiCDdC!7|1ekDLsWgqFUVs3qy)>I2Rq{G!fi@Ut?{QAH z-zj7kwULqhy!NUph8ydfqc5ZOR^=Qy1v^QI2LV|(@Zb_V zl>lcMhcVJb`(A#?q@K` z$8?WJ#-Q1m{6Hrhxt}t0B9Ei2a4p7NcM;6-1b(!qV-j$z;`Vts{cJR~&|%g^=cl&% zHNl(gz{#R-4>8*C6lZberk`3xE`vjsQRWyQWmb>T?LN0kf;PDe-GDC43Bx|V#`4DW z?x!a%y;)QUJ0e{iFc8J-_(IbB)y4e>?6PK?)4X{eT0XoU5=GOSp7b1c@dG7` z{RnPDy6g_uUiY8kmttj~!ghB$k||qAA6-yhvl7qDeYNNO)UgtI!p2{mbHn&GK1y*o z($OQCa}dsyLeG$RbZi3r>gXfb&gpk?5uWKiI(aU?ACC|m@EpquX8D2To)W-7oEKwgRU6JXbCSq5I&3R z;c%al9hn?pS2#bgmkagiB0_*YD9Un}-N2oC9^i&`jshl*02(kb_HRgfsQ8(3v zK3B?mW&ObVf#X}(PEFL9`L5UkL#{DXS00X5Sbr`UG7{w zYV^u$yZQj_t-o>E@MXq`%@)7A63q7$VTPqxlfy3uLx-ZiUSl~WsF>QNpY`$-i90aQ z>cuuk@0&>8kk6{rm#x!nNwS=9;g0JYf^n)i@^;eRmcmoClF;>5?&HNXzaxfbIT7sl4d0uqB-B|AUYV4y7VRxrCkbP zBv8S3leT?u5JKZ4Ss;{R(c=(iCeteGrEMl7mGQWeGf5;CbXr)`~Ub=tqFfLUdrlW{itxIQ3;LEyX zs6aQ`cSUm@3F-1+wyepwq49~pC2Ul?gZOPC`O#wG!cq|5=h;fzLkf0d5>h z4B#mlf`34No=Eh;{Rz@s|5zziKISDJ0?!W~ahB38a)e#_ga;Z+SW6gjujcbK(^N_c zMpMK;C@gu&yH6gfD*)mWTUSK&j@0eh6{NYPJA?2@t-FrHE*ehQ4O_l#=EoR(VwoDM z@7q$fad^{2aXFQSg> zGu$q>a?hKni&cu^M^u-Zb=bhT)Zp2*gBPv%7i^B5^uv=9N-BbIyrgAMN$rP9So5T2 z%`+S>j|M2|_;{-z1_Lq*c0o@OPcesU`6(NOWTNsA>Mxmbs%G$CXlSrJx0?No_$+0R zR;~AT=D4YLS6l2&%>6VS@&j9kS>XE2d|)hQHL1Vh^t~L?y6n5Nm?t1Ime!Bp55^wG zwbYua@dJUMC{s3T?!YNN&_gF0rN(Qz{N_Gd->tJpRWC&6S|}HGbQ$SoVQa4F(Kpnw z>-cu8=^A8SD^*-pbEnL@RJV*QQf;2ctTTyv zt}*)a+R(~e{Hbx4QgU+T_66%lF0z1|L~#h4vh%4O%*3J@dm_-YGpHoGWX`|ny|sDMpGb3PHH4fNBT zI(y~hS#1t3jhluyZyXyt1d9=S>GoxhN`}j+n=jg1LP`f5e80DI*H-V$oQ-As^`w2B zNDpVx>u<~5Y?ll;T1yakUVk>LQ~92{6vP-sOiDa?OhrC@{oS%~*j5o$n1_`OoSwRu zr>|XQ;K_MFO~q4Ow7Qx-d}Dk);q`H*q`DsPruHt+RIRwZH22heEcQK2QV-)ETm|#4 zt%uCc@-MmF(w~tNI?Y`v45SQg*ra_q!fmgq@|t_4(MF;ASq7k8j7U#yv9D*an~)nw zLvIiNJgBKWX8;=ddR5^~^5AOe=4a_}N#cd)Bl69RFE6@^Ml*u?XNSBnp`GnM5|%UR zFAeX`~wU^dS#bYV!h&l+NfzMjPw9XRxfRd5VVBfkE53BM) z$z1#%W%(H#H3)IXoU6>gC%X7D(=7P2 zUwPKtyNF)8acjGM;p&TH=g+?8=DrgQ2yVh-x~;(TZ=<{;k0-|IA1e;YsH|s?Wq;!G zP(jEXbFw|Rp@5dB((@$g9_Kuv@2Z)}vTdcO7^oSVDKL3*k+qFA;{Y9)t>L&2#hNK# zYY`R9@}|ECux;X^P=#g(j-T7=fGJ2VK3l|MCrpNN&I}%z^3OIOM$9PeM40jVy67D=^b}XTS)Bcm_rtO+U&O^^dFLbw zst15sqf=2_{BZqwr>c;XxO6RL%J!M0O_gxc3kvx~P7SOy85T@)>%l<&uho54GgmPR znKIQWAMu?WuSzR&KrT2<5#hHlhT@} zj0@_7h2!S=MXOA#(Z^rF#&-S{Lm!X76xkwdUw(1_LZ6O2SH`7s6LH~-WG7PPIy{~; zi%MZ*+qfIh)N{uG^rl)@ZJ1e`>7-*?aYvq$sVZ53%IwaIQA-fxaC$Gw`-JDFp^V=w zc+*Cu^^TIpUXLG6R3@E7HGm8*I(Oc6n_P_Ou;JwPSnQhYu>Y8KtxCt4j(SAxa!ybX zyv{*u3$C*HMENOJk-YqA|2R}T>24<#w}0UPsPAFZ*G1wCJC*T0p^Zqvhs8vQ%(YCd z45d+>WuZ+o?1w7*skrE9PGF!rmZ|tSpY;RFI?N8R!eV|2?^he_j(Qt%Lh|e8ef5kx zPI5AymtE_5Rt1k1+Rm1b{bA88BdV$+#e4q8Lj$Jo<0!_&f|E|g@mV56WkZ7A8$Vbm z?jH1J_6qIfM4n8d$e~Ya`%F#ho@i9Eo@RZ;YEl{s`uYwg&z@NrUV6_P3&VZBH&K83 z>vurYRnwXi=zIU8ksb;5VOwH|U78}fO#Gy^kwFC%y$y|*psIYqu$>2&d< z-K%&X;Y;Oa>B(4kmHTSPkc^p`{HFwsp$B05v{A?(QlkBBbmb|3krPAjmle(?i3$mY zB;5+#S1Vjf%@BTLFbmO;t4GyHa7`dye8{@BMVoiy2b9 z3C;c}o(9HB^^C-fGE?pEB(5=Z*Ovdm74p!8PlP@@k%)gH_d(uUeR~cY>cV3znR{}O zHwscH=iwrRpQ7Vh#vN+US>|S*9UCM%qh}~@tzVjVku4-mb(1Mu>f>wE+JJ|9Nz9w{ zb0w_rs#ZV2pkXDDqu`fW2~3GPEZO$kF4?ZzewM0luGy#TiQkQnQKpGMDxpjU!N>jt zrp^m{#Ma5x8v9(+?a|gV@8C8yvaYvnu8H5?a@gi3=>{7ptt~lJUZvQ2pMG1qgX$8| zvfrlNcIH`r4LIs$z%!srw<}}rTD6H$v^l;Q#ONIm!q3jeciCb4c)DuT^kwNu6Hj^F zxABBvVl?yFoNju7jI!>QXN}_ZPr36<`ZeA1VNy-9eUxVV-hr!+gZik1`c04SC6o3G zCb@EgvKU4NSO%CQsnPdN_Ez~sgrB5X;3$YRU5H1i@{27)prs%l5}pT5qi)Jd}jYtE|OG4SJ{>_>myAwhj@)XO7*-dD(Dzaj~GGFPaIOz zx@YvRLKR4zHsc*^y)5@8nWI^(dMjRFHhF#t8%kan&}lj9b&_1kb#S=4v~bzU-m08c z|NeFcsLBg%g_rK^Ze(6iugCe2R$zLbIUKsINEzR&$|h=_XvU^`YFSRME^H;75{}2k zmstH|)xC!7jW)?sWtjfUk`!R{_j`z-M$@nI?8AK(J$~;vZLpriY*dRRE?R7E`jc?9 zaFTs`5)E4~*V2^36bKs{WS<@$t%@^WFJFmz`&3iFs8HFKwDUc>+YEQAp6NuzcZ7>Q zXrpr2XKiY)b-8p_TfkATZ`v>#JBtj|W$o*H1tVujgE^%?A>Tq!xVOK| z&}W^~MI1TnDQek~)YJx5K&TS}*bQHMmEGGR<)LK$5CU(M2swhgbpT@CIK~kF#3RTE zf|Lha=7|iG9#S1;9`|^|;zw3kR`U_~(Rt|WjDyOkXDW<~f)8_3^xY%&%C`}u9uDx# z&w({>`(E=g4D@lc@8Jws@{7628$jtR`AWW*;KF23kc`TCjAIE&odOIGL0)C1BrL&M7}Et=<8>|VmOTtZh%Ymuw3 z$2!O?Q%hXaj;Di!iwWCbV}@5NYtK4a$P7$B1a$*h>}yTRo*{TjErj7BY!l1q8t)j{0(uy=9a1cUa%ZzK& zmw{Hcm_BAH6KZkJlvRB&Uit9QDC?9~RK{m=)gg(C};o>m%P!lnbK zE_G8Ld$@5EQ5o?DAkVx`=*7SXP{o4i;g_d8~iG@FSH}^xC$PfsgK<>8WFNLNv#fv=n9P~JyDnW+ zf*$Sj@d|Q{9Sx2$%`MHqr)8X)=gcxm;sMyNQ>#DP4#V6i-6GHjD1n|mk;~Kw41^x8 zPC7bIT6Co`YACyYO#J2zka#*Is{ITg%o`o$=TY9t=Gcc8Y29M%EqF zwuG_|#-pL%-_uk}<1x6fd9!eY$Y_z*nK`{a6`zxB6O zs%mR^=cLEu&fWGS-r+sWFV4OCmHQ+3;uH4HIOF#lOnkB$rH}bH)wyR1D4!8Fjpxyw zz_43F@Lu?5x(IJeY*e=38nJvN2&_;j*JQ@GH79N~7{gXFhH7ka9ZOZ+VSP?pF2Q6A z7%SMf)(d7^__$7{Clf63v%*f^BGd>YyPJ0(^PJbM=@}aDA+4GhIey2|1VHSPYUI+A z);FVl!b?Q;nh~SG>GIT4tn1>uTWF?px!wyeN4 z$znSJAbLJ>`N;hcHzs?L3AFl@I%eN9$0k(XkdOKm_=GF#HJH>rBQ#ak9h<6NA&#k6 zG3NO_RoTZvSFs)aWks1@ICsj?FPAUNE?CNye@jQ6a=qZUT{DflP_E@n4=`ZRCD$%BV14JT-2FQyIMXRx-tOOJvcOR3&( z-Iu?v6QAOZ7|(KB41BzrRBra{3^O9c`d~rT;Ch!1cM3$kXw4fLmU=GaP;tCD_wf9g z^!zdF6M&CZ%MZ-FSMSc_EicgX%ie!nxp7H;t~ENXg~p?UbKd7U=sIS7tR>O6&)oWw zB&mY4>ag4d!k%9CzQ?l0RtH(VGPLihrtFSatB)HY&fU>$qF27>h6YiSo0-Wwv-@hZ-7R#Vcc z4*{66UUjwJuR2y>STimy_#S`sod|h)t|?(Cxtx%INzR^L0{Rbh0wf%S{ZVMVUrVTcaeew_9!idDd3r<01 zS(~S%y7=v@Y&{o}A(91OLXNyi+UrGRmTS*@voZqsrHmWWoCYIxlO7KwbDWcX0Z*EI z9h2Msem4`R?;dCM6BBFOADZ}`vE=--k+ef8Hn`mJ4S-1IX+Wj_iE8@wWyQS) zt+JO(r#asPayV1i^fQ)SHV*pnT;SAB1y%u$u0@uUI^1}_nl$5 z?W$LUYr990Gglv+35l=+yyZ=n8J#6lllT7>6^$qnb-o`EgvDM%Rigqz~0 zFLoDSu!t47iB3dPo%BwE1qHAY4o`vyAy?bEn=LYTT%qZpGRAN9%m#};FMAv?C8M3s ztx#3T!3?z3+O{TW)ZiA8I-E9%;n&}|@v zX>5~q$Jpt@TmuJIz9`2xQ}prIM+$czjgDYO7t*_#{0yv7@*o^d!S0Jg8w*m2g2+X{ z88J2<%UZ+{q^dDnPN1b1LK31mV{v}yr!r#k7fjxJq<9TI^<7n;)4xRVehViuITw9D zFM9&~YTvk_a^TQ6^_1xSPz_m{QFP8-4|M&zjkW>!Wer)`@?}PsJl^) z8b05}k}+HLM;p-R@4C5m?F0&N#Rrux8Zh_yMePkCRDEkl)Xw!*lu*HcE!Gc-0{#OS`xgvQTUqH(C>sYC;7bhSR)F(_MsjehLbIaf+;AZD&hcpA|W@l^fB;Y2@@JmDh*}f%% z7=XW6;5Nbx+RAD`xPybOjTIco$5r~AtvTv zHhwcRUN#O6s5u)F-w9^p;^Z|mh4S-2A^e6`y~6_5`7y$nJ~9sy+sGb?jUqZimgh00*`rF$4w^z&9QCazaUoShm+YNooCm`iu z>THLEx5`WX|7@54wujA3|7EbFGtBl^Y?zsXptjIk+nkV2=0I9(W-4HQi-kw-Y~#OH z7=+xB3?f3vPPi4^7Ao>9^2BZ7e>7~ZZX-#+*4W-cn8A(B3~FxdYzt>Vdg>Rq*&p7p zwG#QG@kqYA(#+dYcOW0Xn}0CjZXG ze?~Rq{}j|rNL=)7j36`2ZIm!d3EYMl2M3sk0|Mds6CW1GN85)3`Sno_z!(x z-v8v|;N*w=%@#P!7zq}KA@6SjK^j&bNSr@65P4t50eL0m7Gn+s$=jPd0Ds}lk!W=( zpq`M73?C;1BF-x%4UyvDm4Qe|ad30+NP;DKAY5R6Zm`Jzox|Yvwu=+o7zY34G^ES< N_yP3v(yB6m{{tx>f?)sv diff --git a/my_reference.bib b/my_reference.bib index 929e65c..5ceb5d6 100644 --- a/my_reference.bib +++ b/my_reference.bib @@ -743,7 +743,7 @@ author = {Lizhe Wang and Samee U. Khan and Dan Chen and Joanna Kołodziej and Ra @INPROCEEDINGS{Spiliopoulos_Green.governors.Adaptive.DVFS, author={Spiliopoulos, V. and Kaxiras, S. and Keramidas, G.}, -booktitle={Green Computing Conference and Workshops (IGCC), 2011 International}, +booktitle={International Green Computing Conference and Workshops (IGCC)}, title={Green governors: A framework for Continuously Adaptive DVFS}, year={2011}, month={July}, -- 2.39.5